Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@jschell
Last active December 22, 2025 17:38
Show Gist options
  • Select an option

  • Save jschell/24ece13fa858042d2b16f5ce86a77fad to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

Select an option

Save jschell/24ece13fa858042d2b16f5ce86a77fad to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Grade 3 Science NGSS requirements

Washington State 3rd Grade Science Requirements

NGSS-Aligned Standards Overview

Document Source: OSPI Science K-12 Learning Standards


Standards Adoption & Background

  • Adoption Date: October 2013
  • Standards Framework: Washington State K-12 Science Learning Standards (WSSLS) are identical to the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS)
  • Current Status: 2024 draft adds Priority Standards and Environmental & Sustainability Education (ESE) while maintaining all NGSS requirements
  • Assessment: Students assessed in Grade 5 via the Washington Comprehensive Assessment of Science (WCAS), which covers grades 3-5 standards

Key Resources:


Three-Dimensional Learning Framework

All standards integrate three dimensions:

1. Science and Engineering Practices (SEPs)

  • Asking Questions and Defining Problems
  • Developing and Using Models
  • Planning and Carrying Out Investigations
  • Analyzing and Interpreting Data
  • Using Mathematics and Computational Thinking
  • Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions
  • Engaging in Argument from Evidence

2. Disciplinary Core Ideas (DCIs)

  • Physical Science (PS)
  • Life Science (LS)
  • Earth and Space Sciences (ESS)
  • Engineering, Technology, and Applications of Science (ETS)

3. Crosscutting Concepts (CCCs)

  • Patterns
  • Cause and Effect: Mechanism and Explanation
  • Scale, Proportion, Quantity
  • Systems and System Models
  • Energy and Matter
  • Structure and Function
  • Stability and Change

3rd Grade Content Standards

Physical Science

How do objects move and interact with other objects?

Priority Standard: WA.3.PS2
Use evidence and data to investigate and measure an object’s motion and how forces affect the motion of objects; use acquired understandings to show how magnetic forces can be used in engineering solutions.

Performance Expectations:

3-PS2-1
Plan and conduct an investigation to provide evidence of the effects of balanced and unbalanced forces on the motion of an object.

3-PS2-2
Make observations and/or measurements of an object’s motion to provide evidence that a pattern can be used to predict future motion.

3-PS2-3
Ask questions to determine cause and effect relationships of electric or magnetic interactions between two objects not in contact with each other.

3-PS2-4 [Engineering]
Define a simple design problem that can be solved by applying scientific ideas about magnets.


Life Science

How do living things grow and develop over their lifetime?

Priority Standard: WA.3.LS1
Use modeling to show, compare, and contrast life cycle patterns.

Performance Expectations:

3-LS1-1
Develop models to describe that organisms have unique and diverse life cycles, but all have in common birth, growth, reproduction, and death.


What makes living things look the way they do? How does appearance affect survival and reproduction?

Priority Standard: WA.3.LS3
Use evidence and data to show and explain inherited and acquired traits; apply understanding of traits to explain how variations can affect survival and reproduction.

Performance Expectations:

3-LS3-1
Analyze and interpret data to provide evidence that plants and animals have traits inherited from parents and that variation of these traits exists in a group of similar organisms.

3-LS3-2 [ESE]
Use evidence to support the explanation that traits can be influenced by the environment.

3-LS4-2
Use evidence to construct an explanation for how the variations in characteristics among individuals of the same species may provide advantages in surviving, finding mates, and reproducing.


How are characteristics, behaviors, and needs of living things related to their environments where they live?

Priority Standard: WA.3.LS4
Use evidence, data, and modeling to show and explain how characteristics and behaviors of living things are related to how well they can survive in their environment; use learned understandings to analyze solutions to problems caused by environmental changes.

Performance Expectations:

3-LS2-1
Construct an argument that some animals form groups that help members survive.

3-LS4-1
Analyze and interpret data from fossils to provide evidence of the organisms and the environments in which they lived long ago.

3-LS4-3 [Climate] [ESE]
Construct an argument with evidence that in a particular habitat some organisms can survive well, some survive less well, and some cannot survive at all.

3-LS4-4 [Engineering] [ESE]
Make a claim about the merit of a solution to a problem caused when the environment changes and the types of plants and animals that live there may change.


Earth and Space Sciences

What is weather and climate like in different places and how does it affect living things?

Priority Standard: WA.3.ESS2
Use research, data, and modeling to show and explain patterns in weather and climate.

Performance Expectations:

3-ESS2-1 [Climate] [ESE]
Represent data in tables and graphical displays to describe typical weather conditions expected during a particular season.

3-ESS2-2 [Climate]
Obtain and combine information to describe climates in different regions of the world.


Priority Standard: WA.3.ESS3
Use engineering thinking to compare and analyze solutions to weather related problems.

Performance Expectations:

3-ESS3-1 [Climate] [Engineering] [ESE]
Make a claim about the merit of a design solution that reduces the impacts of a weather-related hazard.


Engineering, Technology, and Applications of Science

How do we engineer solutions to a problem?

Priority Standard: WA.3.ETS1
Use modeling, investigation, and data to design, test, and improve solutions to problems that can be solved through engineering; include criteria, constraints, and elements of fair tests.

Performance Expectations:

3-5-ETS1-1
Define a simple design problem reflecting a need or a want that includes specified criteria for success and constraints on materials, time, or cost.

3-5-ETS1-2
Generate and compare multiple possible solutions to a problem based on how well each is likely to meet the criteria and constraints of the problem.

3-5-ETS1-3
Plan and carry out fair tests in which variables are controlled and failure points are considered to identify aspects of a model or prototype that can be improved.


Environmental and Sustainability Education

How do we work together to ensure a healthy environment and sustainable economy for future generations?

Priority Standard: WA.3.ESE.1
Through project-based learning, synthesize information from multiple sources about local ecological, social, and economic systems, collaborating with partners and tribes in ways that foster solutions to local environmental problems.

Performance Expectations:

3.ESE.1-1
Cite multiple sources and perspectives in an analysis of and presentation about environmental sustainability in the community, considering values at the individual, community, and tribal level.

3.ESE.1-2
Design an investigation on school grounds to gather, analyze, and present data about how the built environment of the school improves or reduces environmental quality (e.g. impacts on/benefits to water quality, air quality, biodiversity, waste).

3.ESE.1-3
Gather, analyze, and evaluate information, building the knowledge, attitudes, and understanding needed to demonstrate personal and civic responsibility for improved environmental sustainability at the local level.


Special Tags & Annotations

Throughout the standards, you’ll see special tags:

  • [Climate]: Direct or supporting connections to climate science and climate change understanding
  • [Engineering]: Includes engineering disciplinary core ideas and design processes
  • [ESE]: Supports Environmental and Sustainability Education standards implementation

Assessment Information

Washington Comprehensive Assessment of Science (WCAS)

  • Testing Grade for Elementary: Grade 5
  • Grade Band Covered: Tests all standards from grades 3-5
  • Format: Computer-based with multiple choice, technology-enhanced items, and short answer questions
  • Three-Dimensional Assessment: Tests all three dimensions (SEPs, DCIs, CCCs) in integrated performance expectations

Learn more about WCAS


Implementation Resources

Curriculum Evaluation Tools

EdReports
Free reviews of K-12 instructional materials with evidence-rich alignment information
https://www.edreports.org/reports/science

NGSS EQuIP Rubric
Criteria to measure how well lessons and units are designed for NGSS
http://www.nextgenscience.org/resources/equip-rubric-lessons-units-science

EQuIP Detailed Guidance
Support for developing, reviewing, and selecting high-quality NGSS materials
NGSS EQuIP Detailed Guidance (PDF)

OSPI Course Design Resources
Course Design & Instructional Materials

Additional Support

Climate Education Resources
OSPI Climate Education

Outdoor Education for All Program
Outdoor Learning Grant Program

Grants, Resources, and Supports
Science Grants & Resources


Standards Documents

Official OSPI Documents

DCI Arrangements
All standards grouped by Disciplinary Core Ideas
Download PDF

Topic Arrangements
All standards grouped by topic
Download PDF

2024 Draft Learning Standards
Complete K-12 standards with Priority Standards and ESE
Download PDF

National Framework

NRC Framework for K-12 Science Education
The conceptual foundation for NGSS
A Framework for K-12 Science Education


Contact Information

Johanna Brown
Associate Director - Secondary Science Education
Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction
Email: johanna.brown@k12.wa.us

OSPI Main Office
Old Capitol Building
P.O. Box 47200
600 Washington St. SE
Olympia, WA 98504-7200
Phone: 360-725-6000


Quick Reference Summary

3rd Grade Focus Areas

  1. Physical Science: Forces, motion, and magnetism
  2. Life Science: Life cycles, heredity, adaptation, and environmental interactions
  3. Earth Science: Weather patterns, climate, and natural hazards
  4. Engineering: Design process, problem-solving with constraints
  5. Environmental Sustainability: Community-based environmental projects

Key Learning Approaches

  • Hands-on investigations and experiments
  • Data collection and graphical representation
  • Model development and use
  • Evidence-based argumentation
  • Engineering design challenges
  • Place-based environmental learning

PBS LearningMedia Resources for 3rd Grade NGSS

The following curated resources from PBS LearningMedia align with Washington State’s 3rd grade NGSS requirements. Resources are organized by performance expectation.

Physical Science - Forces and Motion

For 3-PS2-1, 3-PS2-2 (Forces and Motion)

Forces and Motion Collection

Balanced and Unbalanced Forces

Describing Motion

Force and Motion | Science Trek

For 3-PS2-3, 3-PS2-4 (Magnetic and Electric Forces)

Magnetic Force Collection

Electric Force Collection

Magnets! | PBS LearningMedia

Teaching Beyond the Textbook with Magnets


Life Science

For 3-LS1-1 (Life Cycles)

Growth and Development | PBS LearningMedia

Growth, Development, and Reproduction | Nature Collection

For 3-LS3-1, 3-LS3-2 (Heredity and Traits)

Inherited Traits

Environmental Effects on Traits

For 3-LS4-1, 3-LS4-3 (Adaptation and Survival)

GPS: Dinosaurs | PBS LearningMedia

Evolution and Adaptation | Think Wednesday Collection

Resilience and Ecosystem Adaptation


Earth and Space Science

For 3-ESS2-1, 3-ESS2-2 (Weather and Climate)

Weather & Climate Collection | NASA-funded

Weather and Climate Main Collection

Using Weather Data to Find Patterns | Lesson Plan

What Is Weather? | Interactive Lesson

Observing Weather Factors | Lesson Plan


Engineering Design

For 3-5-ETS1-1, 3-5-ETS1-2, 3-5-ETS1-3

Teaching NGSS Engineering Design Through Media - Elementary (K-5)

Teaching NGSS Engineering Design Through Media (Main Collection)

How to Teach NGSS Engineering Design to Grades K-5

Introduction to the Engineering Design Process | Engineering for Good

Designing Parachutes: Analyzing Data and Improving Design


Cross-Cutting Collections

SciGirls STEM Collection

SciGirls Main Collection

SciGirls - Physical Science

SciGirls - Environmental Science

NOVA Resources

NOVA Collection on PBS LearningMedia
Aligned to NGSS with videos, interactive resources, and lesson plans across multiple science topics. Organized by NGSS topics with teacher support materials.


General Science Resources

PBS-NC Science Educational Resources


Tips for Using PBS LearningMedia Resources

  1. Filter by Grade Level: Most collections allow filtering - look for K-2 and 3-5 grade bands
  2. Adapt Middle School Resources: Many middle school resources can be simplified for advanced 3rd graders
  3. Combine Resources: Use videos from one resource with lesson plans from another for comprehensive coverage
  4. Professional Development: Watch the PD videos first to understand NGSS implementation
  5. Check Alignments: Each resource lists specific NGSS standards it addresses
  6. Free Access: All PBS LearningMedia resources are free with educator account registration

Additional Resource Discovery

Browse by Standard: Visit https://www.pbslearningmedia.org/subjects/science/ and use the standard alignment filters to find resources specifically aligned to individual 3rd grade NGSS performance expectations.


Last Updated: December 2024
Source: Washington State Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction
PBS LearningMedia Resources Compiled: December 2024

Physical Science - Forces and Motion

3rd Grade NGSS Home Learning Guide

One Student + One Parent/Teacher Format

Total Time: 15-20 hours
Standards Covered: 3-PS2-1, 3-PS2-2, 3-PS2-3, 3-PS2-4


Overview

This unit explores how objects move and interact through forces, motion patterns, and magnetic/electric interactions. The student will conduct hands-on investigations, collect data, and apply learning to engineering design challenges.

Learning Approach

  • Adult Role: Facilitator and co-investigator (not lecturer)
  • Student Role: Active scientist conducting investigations
  • Format: Hands-on investigations with guided questions
  • Assessment: Portfolio of investigations, data, and designs

Unit Sequence

Recommended Order:

  1. Balanced and Unbalanced Forces (3-PS2-1) - 4-5 hours
  2. Motion Patterns (3-PS2-2) - 3-4 hours
  3. Magnetic and Electric Forces (3-PS2-3) - 4-5 hours
  4. Engineering Design Challenge (3-PS2-4) - 4-5 hours

Section 1: Balanced and Unbalanced Forces

Standard: 3-PS2-1
Time: 4-5 hours over 3-4 sessions

Performance Expectation

Plan and conduct an investigation to provide evidence of the effects of balanced and unbalanced forces on the motion of an object.


SETUP

Materials Needed (gather before starting)

Common Household Items:

  • 2-3 toy cars (or any wheeled toys)
  • 2-3 balls (tennis ball, bouncy ball, any ball)
  • 6-10 books of different sizes
  • Building blocks or LEGO
  • Small stuffed animal or action figure
  • Small cardboard box
  • Ruler or measuring tape
  • Stopwatch or phone timer
  • Notebook or printer paper (for data recording)
  • Pencils, markers

Optional but Helpful:

  • Graph paper
  • Masking tape (for marking distances)
  • Smooth floor space or long table

Adult Prep (15 minutes)

Before Session 1:

  1. Watch Video (23 minutes):

  2. Browse Collection (5 minutes):

  3. Create Data Templates (5 minutes):

    • Create simple 3-column table in notebook or print template:
| What I Did | What Happened | Drawing/Notes |
|------------|---------------|---------------|
|            |               |               |
  1. Set Up Investigation Space (5 minutes):
    • Clear floor area or table (at least 6 feet long)
    • Gather all materials in one location
    • Have phone/camera ready to document investigations

Student Prep (10 minutes)

What Student Does:

  1. Gather materials from around house (with adult guidance)
  2. Organize materials by type (cars together, balls together, etc.)
  3. Create science notebook with:
    • Title page: "Forces and Motion Investigation"
    • Date and name
    • Data table (use template above)

INVESTIGATION SESSIONS

Session 1: What Are Forces? (60-75 minutes)

Objective: Discover that forces are pushes and pulls that cause objects to move or stop.

Part 1: Free Exploration (20 minutes)

Student Does:

  1. Take toy car and ball
  2. Find 5 different ways to make each object move
  3. For each method, write in notebook: What did you do?

Adult Does:

  • Observe without directing
  • Ask open-ended questions:
    • "What made it move?"
    • "Did you push or pull?"
    • "What happened when you pushed harder?"
  • Take photos/videos of student discoveries

Expected Discoveries:

  • Pushing makes things move
  • Pulling makes things move
  • Harder pushes = faster/farther motion
  • Gentle pushes = slower/shorter motion

Part 2: Guided Investigation - Identifying Forces (20 minutes)

Adult Guides With Questions:

  1. "Show me a push force" → Student demonstrates
  2. "Show me a pull force" → Student demonstrates
  3. "What's happening to the object when you push/pull?" → Discuss motion

Activity:

  • Together, walk around house
  • Identify 10 forces in action:
    • Opening door (pull)
    • Closing door (push)
    • Sitting (push from chair)
    • Picking up object (pull from hand)
  • Student records in notebook with simple drawings

Key Vocabulary to Introduce:

  • Force: A push or a pull
  • Motion: When something changes position

Part 3: Video Learning (15 minutes)

Watch Together:

Pause Points for Discussion:

  • When video shows push/pull: "Can you find something in our house that works the same way?"
  • When showing motion: "Why did that object move?"

Part 4: Demonstration and Recording (20 minutes)

Structured Demonstrations - Student performs, adult records:

  1. Gentle Push:

    • Push car gently across floor
    • Measure how far it goes
    • Record distance
  2. Medium Push:

    • Push same car with medium force
    • Measure distance
    • Record
  3. Hard Push:

    • Push same car hard
    • Measure distance
    • Record

Data Recording:

Push Strength | Distance Traveled | Drawing
Gentle        | ___ cm/inches     | [sketch]
Medium        | ___ cm/inches     | [sketch]
Hard          | ___ cm/inches     | [sketch]

Discussion Questions (Adult asks):

  • "What pattern do you see in your data?"
  • "Why did the car go farther with a harder push?"
  • "Is this what you predicted would happen?"

Session 2: Balanced Forces (60-75 minutes)

Objective: Discover that balanced forces cause no change in motion.

Part 1: Introduction Activity (10 minutes)

Setup:

  • Find sturdy book (hardcover)
  • Place on smooth table

Adult and Student Together:

  1. Both push book from opposite sides with equal gentle force
  2. Observe: Book doesn't move
  3. Adult pushes harder while student keeps same force
  4. Observe: Book moves toward student
  5. Both stop pushing
  6. Observe: Book stays still

Adult Asks:

  • "When did the book move? When did it stay still?"
  • "What was different between the two situations?"

Introduce Term:

  • Balanced Forces = Equal forces in opposite directions (no motion change)

Part 2: Tug-of-War Simulation (15 minutes)

Materials:

  • Stuffed animal or toy
  • Table edge

Investigation:

Test 1 - Balanced:

  • Student pulls toy toward them gently
  • Adult pulls toy toward them with equal gentle force
  • Observe: Toy doesn't move (balanced forces)
  • Student draws diagram with arrows showing forces

Test 2 - Unbalanced:

  • Student pulls with same gentle force
  • Adult pulls harder
  • Observe: Toy moves toward adult (unbalanced forces)
  • Student draws diagram with arrows (make adult's arrow longer)

Test 3 - No Forces:

  • Both let go
  • Observe: Toy sits still
  • Discuss: Gravity pulls down, table pushes up (balanced)

Student Records:

Situation          | Balanced or Unbalanced? | What Happened?
Both pull equal    |                         |
Adult pulls harder |                         |
No one pulling     |                         |

Part 3: Finding Balanced Forces (25 minutes)

Challenge: Find 5 examples of balanced forces

Student Explores House:

  1. Objects sitting still on surfaces (gravity down, surface up)
  2. Books on shelf (gravity down, shelf up)
  3. Picture on wall (gravity down, hook/wall up)
  4. Student sitting in chair (gravity down, chair up)
  5. Object in hand (gravity down, hand up)

For Each Example:

  • Student draws simple diagram
  • Labels the two forces with arrows
  • Adult asks: "Why isn't it moving?"

Part 4: Ramp Investigation (20-25 minutes)

Setup:

  • Create ramp using book and ruler/board
  • Place toy car at top

Investigation Questions:

Question 1: "What forces act on the car at rest on the ramp?"

  • Gravity pulling down
  • Ramp pushing back up
  • Student's hand holding it (if applicable)
  • Are they balanced? (Yes, if car isn't moving)

Question 2: "What happens when we let go?"

  • Remove hand
  • Observe: Car rolls down
  • Why? Forces become unbalanced (gravity wins)

Question 3: "Can we balance the car again?"

  • Try: Pushing gently up ramp while gravity pulls down
  • Find exact push to keep car still
  • This is balancing forces!

Student Creates:

  • Before/After diagrams showing balanced vs. unbalanced forces on ramp

Session 3: Unbalanced Forces Investigation (90 minutes)

Objective: Investigate how unbalanced forces affect motion and collect measurable data.

Part 1: Planning Investigation (15 minutes)

Question to Investigate: "How does the strength of a push affect how far an object moves?"

Adult and Student Plan Together:

What will we test?

  • Toy car on smooth floor

What will we change?

  • Strength of push (gentle, medium, hard)

What will we measure?

  • Distance car travels

How will we keep it fair?

  • Same car every time
  • Same floor surface
  • Same starting position
  • Same person pushing

Student Writes:

  • Investigation question in notebook
  • Prediction: "I think..."
  • List of materials needed
  • Step-by-step procedure

Part 2: Conducting Investigation (30 minutes)

Setup:

  • Mark starting line with tape or book
  • Clear path of at least 6 feet

Procedure (Student Performs, Adult Records):

Trial Set 1 - Gentle Push:

  1. Place car at starting line
  2. Push gently (just enough to move it)
  3. Let car roll to stop
  4. Measure distance from start to where car stopped
  5. Record in data table
  6. Repeat 2 more times (3 trials total)

Trial Set 2 - Medium Push:

  1. Place car at starting line
  2. Push with medium force
  3. Measure and record
  4. Repeat 2 more times

Trial Set 3 - Hard Push:

  1. Place car at starting line
  2. Push hard (but safely)
  3. Measure and record
  4. Repeat 2 more times

Data Table:

Push Strength | Trial 1 (cm) | Trial 2 (cm) | Trial 3 (cm) | Average
Gentle        |              |              |              |
Medium        |              |              |              |
Hard          |              |              |              |

Adult Helps:

  • Keep push strength consistent within each set
  • Help with measuring if needed
  • Ensure data is recorded accurately

Part 3: Analysis and Graphing (30 minutes)

Calculate Averages (10 minutes):

  • Student adds three trials for each push strength
  • Divides by 3 to get average
  • Adult checks math

Create Bar Graph (15 minutes):

Adult Provides:

  • Graph paper or draw simple graph template
  • X-axis: Push Strength (Gentle, Medium, Hard)
  • Y-axis: Distance (in cm)

Student Does:

  • Draw bars showing average distance for each push strength
  • Label axes
  • Title: "How Push Strength Affects Distance"
  • Color code bars

Discussion Questions (5 minutes):

Adult asks, student responds (record answers):

  1. "What pattern do you see in your graph?"
    • Expected: Harder pushes = farther distance
  2. "Why do you think this happened?"
    • Expected: Bigger force creates more motion
  3. "If you pushed even harder, what would happen?"
    • Expected: Car would go even farther
  4. "What force made the car stop rolling?"
    • Expected: Friction from floor

Part 4: Extension - Ramp Experiment (15 minutes)

Quick Investigation:

Setup:

  • Create 3 ramps using books:
    • Ramp 1: 1 book under ruler
    • Ramp 2: 2 books under ruler
    • Ramp 3: 3 books under ruler

Test:

  • Release car from top of each ramp
  • Measure distance it rolls after leaving ramp
  • Record which ramp made car go farthest

Discussion:

  • "Steeper ramp = more force from gravity"
  • "More force = more distance traveled"
  • Connect back to main investigation

End of Session Documentation:

  • Take photos of data table and graph
  • Student writes: "Today I learned that stronger forces cause objects to move farther because..."

Session 4: Real-World Forces Portfolio (45 minutes)

Objective: Apply understanding of balanced and unbalanced forces to real situations.

Part 1: Photo Hunt (20 minutes)

Activity: Find and photograph 5 examples of forces around your home

Requirements for Each Photo:

  1. Take photo showing force in action
  2. Label photo with:
    • What force is shown? (push or pull)
    • Is it balanced or unbalanced?
    • How do you know?

Example Photos:

  • Door handle (pull to open - unbalanced)
  • Book on shelf (gravity down, shelf up - balanced)
  • Refrigerator magnets (magnetic force - balanced on fridge)
  • Person sitting (gravity down, chair up - balanced)
  • Pushing shopping cart (push - unbalanced, creates motion)

Adult Role:

  • Help with camera/phone
  • Ask guiding questions: "What forces do you see?"
  • Don't give answers - let student think through it

Part 2: Force Diagrams (15 minutes)

For 3 of the Photos:

Student creates scientific diagram:

  1. Draw simple sketch of situation
  2. Add arrows showing forces:
    • Direction arrow points
    • Label each arrow (gravity, push from hand, etc.)
    • Make arrow size show force strength
  3. Write: Balanced or Unbalanced?
  4. Explain: What's happening to the object?

Adult Provides:

  • Example diagram to model format
  • Feedback on arrow accuracy

Part 3: Written Explanation (10 minutes)

Student Writes (in science notebook):

"What I Learned About Forces"

  • A force is...
  • Balanced forces cause...
  • Unbalanced forces cause...
  • I see forces in my everyday life when...
  • One question I still have is...

Completion Criteria:

  • At least 5 sentences
  • Uses vocabulary: force, push, pull, balanced, unbalanced, motion
  • Includes at least one specific example

COMPLETION CHECKLIST - Section 1

Student has completed when they have:

  • Data table with 9 measurements (3 push strengths × 3 trials)
  • Calculated averages for all three push strengths
  • Bar graph showing relationship between push strength and distance
  • 5 photos of real-world forces with labels
  • 3 detailed force diagrams with arrows
  • Written reflection explaining forces and motion
  • Notebook with all investigations documented

Time Investment:

  • Session 1: 60-75 minutes
  • Session 2: 60-75 minutes
  • Session 3: 90 minutes
  • Session 4: 45 minutes
  • Total: 4-5 hours

Section 2: Motion Patterns

Standard: 3-PS2-2
Time: 3-4 hours over 2-3 sessions

Performance Expectation

Make observations and/or measurements of an object's motion to provide evidence that a pattern can be used to predict future motion.


SETUP

Materials Needed

Essential:

  • Toy car or any rolling object
  • Books (3-5 different sizes)
  • Ruler or board for ramp
  • Measuring tape or meter stick
  • Stopwatch or phone timer
  • Masking tape
  • Notebook, graph paper
  • Pencil

Optional:

  • Ball
  • String and weight (for pendulum)
  • Wind-up toy

Adult Prep (10 minutes)

Before Session 1:

  1. Browse Collection (5 minutes):

  2. Create Graph Templates (5 minutes):

    • Draw blank graph on paper or print:
    • X-axis: Time (seconds) - labels 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
    • Y-axis: Distance from start (cm) - labels 0, 20, 40, 60, 80, 100
  3. Set Up Measurement Track:

    • Use masking tape on floor to create track
    • Mark starting line (0)
    • Mark lines every 20 cm for 2 meters (or every 6 inches)
    • Label each line with distance

Student Prep (5 minutes)

What Student Does:

  1. Help adult create measurement track with tape
  2. Practice using stopwatch: start, stop, read time
  3. Set up science notebook with:
    • Title: "Motion Patterns Investigation"
    • Data table template (adult provides)

INVESTIGATION SESSIONS

Session 1: Measuring and Graphing Motion (90 minutes)

Objective: Discover that regular motion creates predictable patterns that can be graphed.

Part 1: Introduction - Mystery Motion (10 minutes)

Activity:

  • Adult walks across room at steady, slow pace
  • Student closes eyes
  • Adult asks: "If I keep walking like this, where will I be in 5 more seconds?"
  • Student predicts by pointing
  • Adult continues walking, check prediction

Discussion:

  • "How did you make your guess?"
  • "I was moving in a pattern - steady speed"
  • "Today we'll use patterns to predict motion"

Part 2: Recording Position Over Time (30 minutes)

Investigation: Track where a rolling car is at each second

Setup:

  • Create ramp with book + ruler
  • Position at top of measurement track
  • Student gets stopwatch ready

Procedure (do 3 complete trials):

Roles:

  • Adult: Releases car at "Go", calls time every second ("1... 2... 3... 4... 5...")
  • Student: Marks where car is when each number is called OR records distance on pre-marked track

How to Mark Position: Method A: Put small piece of tape where car is at each second Method B: Record which distance line (20cm, 40cm, etc.) car is closest to

Data Recording (Example):

Trial 1:
Time (sec) | Distance from Start (cm)
0          | 0
1          | 15
2          | 35
3          | 52
4          | 68
5          | 85

Repeat for Trials 2 and 3

Adult's Role:

  • Keep time calls consistent
  • Help student stay focused on car position
  • Assist with measurements if needed

Part 3: Creating Motion Graph (25 minutes)

Student Task: Turn data into visual graph

Step-by-Step (adult guides):

  1. Set Up Graph (5 min):

    • Label X-axis: Time (seconds)
    • Label Y-axis: Distance from start (cm)
    • Title: "Car Rolling Down Ramp"
  2. Plot Points (10 min):

    • For each time/distance pair, make a dot
    • Example: At time = 1 sec, distance = 15 cm, put dot at that intersection
    • Plot all points from Trial 1
  3. Connect Points (5 min):

    • Draw line connecting all dots
    • What shape is the line?
  4. Add Trials 2 and 3 (5 min) - Optional:

    • Use different colors
    • Plot on same graph
    • Compare: Are lines similar?

Discussion Questions:

Adult asks:

  • "Describe the shape of your line"
    • Expected: Straight, diagonal, going up
  • "What does this line tell us?"
    • Expected: Car keeps moving, gaining distance each second
  • "Is the car moving at the same speed the whole time?"
    • Look at line: Straight = yes, steady speed

Part 4: Using Patterns to Predict (25 minutes)

Challenge: Use your graph to predict the future!

Question: "Based on your pattern, where will the car be at 6 seconds? 7 seconds?"

Student Does:

  1. Extend graph lines (use dotted line)
  2. Read predicted positions from extended line
  3. Write predictions:
    • At 6 seconds: _____ cm
    • At 7 seconds: _____ cm

Test Predictions:

  • Run investigation again
  • Time 6 and 7 seconds
  • Measure actual positions
  • Compare to predictions

Calculate Accuracy:

Predicted at 6 sec: ___ cm
Actual at 6 sec: ___ cm
Difference: ___ cm
Was I close? ___

Discussion:

  • "How close was your prediction?"
  • "Why was the graph useful?"
  • "Would this work if the car was speeding up or slowing down?"

Session 2: Different Motion Patterns (60-90 minutes)

Objective: Discover that different types of motion create different graph patterns.

Part 1: Pendulum Investigation (30 minutes)

Setup:

  • Tie weight to 50cm string
  • Hang from doorway or have adult hold
  • Create simple pendulum

Investigation: Do pendulums swing in predictable patterns?

Question: "How many times will it swing in 30 seconds?"

Procedure:

Trial 1:

  1. Pull weight to side, release
  2. Count complete swings in 30 seconds
  3. Record: ____ swings

Trial 2:

  1. Same setup, repeat
  2. Count swings
  3. Record

Trial 3:

  1. Same setup, repeat
  2. Count swings
  3. Record

Data:

Trial | Number of Swings in 30 sec
1     |
2     |
3     |
Average: ____

Prediction:

  • Based on pattern, predict swings in 60 seconds: ____
  • Test by counting for full 60 seconds
  • Actual swings: ____
  • How accurate? ____

Discussion:

  • "Did the pendulum swing the same number of times each 30 seconds?"
  • "Yes! This is a repeating pattern"
  • "Repeating patterns are very predictable"

Part 2: Comparing Motion Patterns (30 minutes)

Activity: Create graphs of different motions

Motion 1 - Steady Walking:

  • Mark 5 spots on floor (20 cm apart)
  • Student walks steadily, adult calls: "Stop!" at 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 seconds
  • Record position at each time
  • Graph it - should be straight line

Motion 2 - Getting Faster:

  • Student starts walking slowly, gradually speeds up
  • Adult calls times, student notes positions
  • Graph it - should curve upward more steeply
  • Pattern: Distance increasing MORE each second

Motion 3 - Getting Slower:

  • Student starts fast, gradually slows down
  • Record and graph
  • Pattern: Distance increasing LESS each second

Student Draws All Three Graphs (can be on same axes with different colors)

Analysis: Adult and student compare:

  • "How are the graphs different?"
  • "What does a straight line mean?" (Steady speed)
  • "What does a curving line mean?" (Speed changing)

Part 3: Prediction Challenge (15-30 minutes) - Optional Extension

Setup Challenges:

Challenge 1: Ball Roll:

  • Roll ball down ramp
  • Measure position at 1, 2, 3 seconds
  • Create quick mini-graph
  • Predict: Where at 4 seconds?
  • Test and verify

Challenge 2: Wind-Up Toy (if available):

  • Wind toy same amount each time
  • Measure how far it goes (3 trials)
  • Find average
  • Predict: How far on trial 4?
  • Test
  • Calculate accuracy: How close?

Challenge 3: Bouncing Ball:

  • Drop ball from same height 5 times
  • Measure first bounce height each time
  • Find average
  • Predict 6th bounce
  • Test

Scoring:

  • Within 5 cm: Excellent prediction!
  • Within 10 cm: Good prediction
  • Within 20 cm: Okay prediction
  • Discuss: What made predicting easy or hard?

COMPLETION CHECKLIST - Section 2

Student has completed when they have:

  • Data table with position recorded at 1-second intervals (3 trials)
  • Graph showing position vs. time for rolling car
  • Extended graph with predictions for times 6 and 7 seconds
  • Tested predictions and calculated accuracy
  • Pendulum swing data (3 trials + prediction test)
  • 3 different motion pattern graphs (steady, speeding up, slowing down)
  • At least one prediction challenge completed successfully
  • Written explanation: "Patterns in motion help us predict because..."

Time Investment:

  • Session 1: 90 minutes
  • Session 2: 60-90 minutes
  • Total: 3-4 hours

Section 3: Magnetic and Electric Forces

Standard: 3-PS2-3
Time: 4-5 hours over 3-4 sessions

Performance Expectation

Ask questions to determine cause and effect relationships of electric or magnetic interactions between two objects not in contact with each other.


SETUP

Materials Needed

Magnets (can buy inexpensively online or at craft stores):

  • Bar magnets (2) - preferably with N/S labeled or mark yourself
  • Refrigerator magnets (3-4)
  • Magnetic wands or horseshoe magnets (optional)

Magnetic Items:

  • Paper clips (20-30)
  • Steel washers (10-15)
  • Nails or screws (10-15)
  • Keys (metal)
  • Coins (quarters, nickels - test first, some aren't magnetic)
  • Scissors (metal parts)

Non-Magnetic Items:

  • Plastic items (toys, utensils, clips)
  • Pennies (made of zinc/copper, not magnetic)
  • Aluminum foil
  • Rubber bands
  • Wooden items
  • Paper, cardboard
  • Glass

For Static Electricity:

  • Balloons (5-6)
  • Wool cloth or sweater
  • Plastic comb
  • Tissue paper or newspaper (torn into small pieces)
  • Puffed rice cereal or small paper scraps

For Investigations:

  • Sheets of paper (10-20)
  • Cardboard
  • Plastic folders or sheets
  • Ruler
  • Notebook

Adult Prep (15 minutes)

Before Starting:

  1. Watch Video (8 minutes):

  2. Browse Collection (5 minutes):

  3. Label Magnets (2 minutes):

    • If magnets don't have poles marked:
    • Test which ends attract/repel
    • Use stickers or marker: Label one end "N" (north), other "S" (south)
    • Do this for all bar magnets

Safety Note: Keep magnets away from electronics, credit cards, pacemakers

Student Prep (10 minutes)

What Student Does:

  1. Sort items into bins:
    • Bin 1: Items you think ARE magnetic
    • Bin 2: Items you think are NOT magnetic
    • Bin 3: Not sure
  2. Set up science notebook:
    • Title: "Magnetic Forces Investigation"
    • Create testing chart (template below)
  3. Gather balloons and wool cloth for static electricity

INVESTIGATION SESSIONS

Session 1: Discovering Magnetic Forces (60-75 minutes)

Objective: Discover what magnets attract and how they interact with each other.

Part 1: Mystery Force Demo (10 minutes)

Demonstration:

  1. Adult places paper clip on table
  2. Adult holds magnet UNDER table
  3. Adult moves magnet - paper clip moves without being touched!
  4. Student tries it

Discussion:

  • "How is this possible?"
  • "The magnet works through the table"
  • "The magnet pulls the paper clip even without touching it"

Student Questions:

  • Record 3-5 questions about magnets in notebook
  • Examples: "What can magnets stick to?", "How far away does it work?", "Can magnets push things?"

Part 2: Testing Magnetic vs. Non-Magnetic (25 minutes)

Investigation: Which items are attracted to magnets?

Prediction First:

  • Student looks at all sorted items
  • Reviews predictions (which bins items are in)
  • Records predictions in table

Testing:

  • Student tests each item with magnet
  • Does it stick? Yes or No
  • Record results

Data Table:

Item           | Prediction (Yes/No) | Actual Result (Yes/No) | Magnetic?
Paper clip     |                     |                        |
Penny          |                     |                        |
Nail           |                     |                        |
Plastic toy    |                     |                        |
Aluminum foil  |                     |                        |
Scissors       |                     |                        |
Rubber band    |                     |                        |
[add more...]  |                     |                        |

Analysis Questions:

Adult asks:

  • "What do the magnetic items have in common?"
    • Expected: They're metal (specifically iron/steel)
  • "Were any of your predictions wrong? Which ones?"
  • "Why do you think aluminum foil didn't stick?"
    • Different type of metal

Create Categories:

  • Magnetic: Iron, steel, nickel, cobalt
  • Not Magnetic: Plastic, wood, paper, most metals (aluminum, copper, brass)

Part 3: Magnet Poles - Attraction and Repulsion (25 minutes)

Investigation: How do two magnets interact?

Watch First (8 minutes):

Hands-On Testing (17 minutes):

Test 1 - Finding Poles:

  1. Take two bar magnets
  2. Hold one steady on table
  3. Bring second magnet close
  4. Try different orientations (flip magnet around)
  5. Observe: Sometimes they pull together, sometimes push apart

Observations:

Magnet Ends Facing | What Happened? (attract/repel)
N to N             |
N to S             |
S to N             |
S to S             |

Pattern Discovery:

  • "What pattern do you see?"
  • Expected finding:
    • N to N = REPEL (push apart)
    • S to S = REPEL (push apart)
    • N to S = ATTRACT (pull together)
    • S to N = ATTRACT (pull together)

Rule: Opposite poles attract, same poles repel

Test 2 - Feeling the Force:

  • Hold magnets with same poles facing
  • Push gently together
  • Feel them push back
  • "You can FEEL the force even though magnets aren't touching!"

Vocabulary (write in notebook with examples):

  • Attract: Pull together
  • Repel: Push apart
  • Poles: The two ends of a magnet (N and S)
  • Magnetic Force: Works without touching

Part 4: Documentation (10-15 minutes)

Student Creates:

  1. Diagram of Magnetic Attraction:

    • Draw two magnets with opposite poles facing
    • Add arrows showing force direction
    • Label: "Attract - opposite poles pull together"
  2. Diagram of Magnetic Repulsion:

    • Draw two magnets with same poles facing
    • Add arrows showing force pushing apart
    • Label: "Repel - same poles push apart"
  3. List:

    • 5 magnetic items found
    • 5 non-magnetic items found
    • Pattern statement: "Magnets attract items made of..."

Session 2: Magnetic Force at a Distance (60 minutes)

Objective: Investigate how magnetic force works through materials and over distance.

Part 1: Force Through Materials (30 minutes)

Investigation Question: Can magnetic force work through things?

Setup:

  • Paper clip on table
  • Magnet
  • Various materials: paper, cardboard, plastic folder, wooden board, aluminum foil

Test 1 - Through Paper:

  • Place 1 sheet of paper on table
  • Put paper clip on top of paper
  • Hold magnet under paper
  • Move magnet - does clip move?
  • Record: YES or NO

Continue Testing:

  • Add papers one at a time
  • Test: How many sheets before magnetism doesn't work?
  • Record maximum number

Test 2 - Different Materials:

  • Test with: cardboard, plastic, wood, aluminum foil
  • For each, record: Does magnetic force work through it?

Data Table:

Material       | Did Magnet Work? (Yes/No) | Notes
1 sheet paper  |                           |
5 sheets paper |                           |
10 sheets paper|                           |
Cardboard      |                           |
Plastic folder |                           |
Wood block     |                           |
Aluminum foil  |                           |

Findings:

  • "Magnetic force works through non-magnetic materials"
  • "But it gets weaker as distance increases"
  • "Eventually, too far = doesn't work"

Part 2: Measuring Magnetic Strength (30 minutes)

Investigation: Which magnet is strongest?

Method: Paper clip chain test

Procedure (for each magnet you have):

  1. Touch magnet to one paper clip
  2. Touch second clip to first clip
  3. Keep adding clips to make chain
  4. When chain breaks, count how many clips were connected
  5. Record number
  6. Repeat 2 more times
  7. Calculate average

Data:

Magnet Type      | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Average
Bar magnet #1    |         |         |         |
Bar magnet #2    |         |         |         |
Fridge magnet    |         |         |         |
Horseshoe magnet |         |         |         |

Analysis:

  • Create bar graph showing average clips for each magnet
  • Rank magnets from strongest to weakest
  • Discussion: "Why might some magnets be stronger?"

Extension - Distance Test:

  • Place paper clip on table
  • Slowly bring magnet closer from above
  • Measure: How far away when clip first moves?
  • Stronger magnets = work from farther away

Session 3: Static Electricity (45-60 minutes)

Objective: Discover electric forces and compare to magnetic forces.

Note: This is a simplified introduction to electricity, appropriate for 3rd grade.

Part 1: Static Electricity Demonstrations (20 minutes)

Demo 1 - Balloon and Paper:

Procedure:

  1. Tear tissue paper into tiny pieces (confetti-size)
  2. Rub balloon on wool cloth or hair (15-20 times in same direction)
  3. Bring balloon close to paper pieces
  4. Observe: They jump to balloon!

Discussion:

  • "Is this magnetism?" (No - paper isn't metal)
  • "This is ELECTRIC force"
  • "Electric charge builds up on balloon from rubbing"

Demo 2 - Plastic Comb:

  1. Rub plastic comb on hair/wool
  2. Hold near small paper scraps
  3. Observe attraction
  4. Try near: puffed rice, hair (hold near but don't touch)

Demo 3 - Repulsion:

  1. Rub two balloons on hair/wool
  2. Try to bring them close together
  3. Feel them push apart - they repel!

Observations:

Test              | What Happened?
Balloon + paper   |
Comb + hair       |
Two balloons      |

Part 2: Compare Electric and Magnetic Forces (15 minutes)

Create Venn Diagram:

Magnetic Forces (left circle):

  • Only work on iron/steel
  • Always work (don't wear off)
  • Need special magnet object

Both (middle overlap):

  • Work without touching
  • Can attract AND repel
  • Get weaker with distance
  • Invisible forces

Electric Forces (right circle):

  • Work on many materials (paper, hair, etc.)
  • Temporary (wears off in minutes)
  • Can create by rubbing

Adult Asks:

  • "How are these forces similar?"
  • "How are they different?"
  • "Which force would be better for picking up paper clips? Why?"

Part 3: Investigation Design (20-25 minutes)

Student Challenge: Design your own test!

Choose One Question to Investigate:

  1. "Does rubbing longer make static electricity stronger?"
  2. "Which materials create the best static electricity?"
  3. "How long does static electricity last?"
  4. "Can static electricity work through materials like magnetism can?"

For Chosen Question:

Plan:

  • Write question
  • Predict answer
  • List materials needed
  • Write step-by-step procedure
  • Identify: What will you change? What will you measure?

Conduct:

  • Follow your procedure
  • Collect data
  • Record observations

Results:

  • What did you find out?
  • Was your prediction correct?
  • Draw diagram or create data table

Adult's Role:

  • Help refine testable question
  • Ensure procedure is safe and feasible
  • Guide data collection
  • Don't give answers - let student discover

COMPLETION CHECKLIST - Section 3

Student has completed when they have:

  • Data table testing at least 10 items (magnetic vs. non-magnetic)
  • Observations table showing magnet pole interactions (N-N, N-S, S-N, S-S)
  • Diagrams of attraction and repulsion with labeled force arrows
  • Test results: magnetic force through different materials
  • Magnet strength comparison data (paper clip chain test)
  • Static electricity observations (at least 3 demonstrations)
  • Venn diagram comparing magnetic and electric forces
  • Student-designed investigation with question, procedure, data, and results
  • Written reflection: "Magnetic and electric forces are different from other forces because..."

Time Investment:

  • Session 1: 60-75 minutes
  • Session 2: 60 minutes
  • Session 3: 45-60 minutes
  • Total: 4-5 hours

Section 4: Engineering Design with Magnets

Standard: 3-PS2-4
Time: 4-5 hours over 2-3 sessions

Performance Expectation

Define a simple design problem that can be solved by applying scientific ideas about magnets.


SETUP

Materials Needed

Magnets:

  • Bar magnets (2-3)
  • Small magnets or magnetic strips
  • Refrigerator magnets

Building Materials (gather from around house):

  • Cardboard (cereal boxes, shipping boxes)
  • Toilet paper or paper towel tubes
  • Popsicle sticks or straws
  • String or yarn
  • Tape (masking tape, clear tape)
  • Glue or glue stick
  • Rubber bands
  • Paper clips
  • Small cups or containers

Testing Materials:

  • Metal washers (10-20)
  • Paper clips
  • Small metal objects
  • Ruler/measuring tape
  • Stopwatch

Adult Prep (20 minutes)

Before Starting:

  1. Watch Video (12 minutes):

  2. Browse Collection (5 minutes):

  3. Choose Design Challenge (3 minutes):

    • Review three challenge options below
    • Select ONE based on available materials and student interest
    • Gather specific materials for that challenge

Student Prep (15 minutes)

What Student Does:

  1. Help adult gather building materials from around house
  2. Organize materials into labeled containers
  3. Set up engineering notebook:
    • Title: "Engineering Design: Magnet Challenge"
    • Sections: Problem, Ideas, Plan, Build, Test, Improve
  4. Review what was learned about magnets (from Section 3)

ENGINEERING SESSIONS

Session 1: Understanding the Problem (45-60 minutes)

Objective: Define an engineering problem and identify criteria and constraints.

Part 1: Introduction to Engineering (10 minutes)

Discussion:

Adult explains:

  • "Scientists try to understand HOW things work"
  • "Engineers use that understanding to SOLVE PROBLEMS"
  • "You've been a scientist learning about magnets"
  • "Now you'll be an engineer using magnets to solve a problem!"

Video (5 minutes):

Part 2: Analyze Example Problem (15 minutes)

Example: Refrigerator magnet paper holder

Together, Identify:

Problem it solves:

  • Need to display papers on refrigerator without making holes

How it works:

  • Uses magnetic attraction
  • Magnet sticks to metal refrigerator
  • Holds paper between magnet and fridge

Criteria (what it MUST do):

  • Hold at least one sheet of paper
  • Stick to refrigerator reliably
  • Easy to add and remove papers

Constraints (limitations):

  • Must be small enough to store easily
  • Can't scratch refrigerator surface
  • Must use magnetic force

Student Writes in notebook:

  • Problem: ___
  • Criteria (requirements): ___
  • Constraints (limitations): ___

Part 3: Choose Your Challenge (15-20 minutes)

CHALLENGE OPTION A: Magnetic Retrieval Tool

The Problem: Small metal washers have fallen into a tall, narrow container (toilet paper tube or cup). Your hand won't fit inside. Design a tool to get the washers out using magnetic force.

Criteria (success requirements):

  • Must remove at least 5 washers from container
  • Can't reach fingers into container
  • Must use magnetic force to retrieve items

Constraints (limitations):

  • Materials: Choose from - magnets (1-2), string, tape, sticks/straws, paper clips
  • Time: 45 minutes to build
  • Tool must fit through container opening

CHALLENGE OPTION B: Magnetic Maze Game

The Problem: Design an entertaining game where a player moves an object through a maze without touching the object directly.

Criteria (success requirements):

  • Object must navigate through complete maze (start to finish)
  • Player controls movement using magnet (not touching object)
  • Maze has at least 3 turns
  • Clear start and finish points

Constraints (limitations):

  • Materials: Cardboard (one piece), magnets (1-2), paper clips, markers, tape
  • Maze must fit on single piece of cardboard
  • Must work through cardboard thickness (magnet below, object above)

CHALLENGE OPTION C: Magnetic Separator

The Problem: You have a mixed collection of magnetic and non-magnetic items that need to be sorted quickly for recycling.

Criteria (success requirements):

  • Separates magnetic items from non-magnetic items
  • Works in under 2 minutes for 20 mixed items
  • Doesn't require picking up each item individually
  • Magnetic items collected in container

Constraints (limitations):

  • Materials: Magnets, containers, cardboard, tape, string
  • Must be operated by one person
  • Must not damage or scratch items being sorted
  • Design must be reusable

Student Selects Challenge:

  • Read all three options
  • Choose one
  • Write in notebook:
    • Which challenge I chose: ___
    • Why I chose this one: ___
    • Copy criteria and constraints for chosen challenge

Part 4: Ask Questions (10-15 minutes)

Generate Questions:

Student thinks about challenge and writes questions:

  • "What do I need to know to solve this?"
  • "What could go wrong?"
  • "How will magnetic force help?"

Example Questions for Retrieval Tool:

  • How strong does the magnet need to be?
  • Will string or stick work better to reach washers?
  • How will I pull the tool back out?

Adult's Role:

  • Ask prompting questions
  • Help student think through the problem
  • DON'T provide solutions
  • Questions to ask:
    • "What do you know about magnets that might help?"
    • "What challenges do you think you'll face?"
    • "How will you test if it works?"

Session 2: Design and Build (90-120 minutes)

Objective: Brainstorm solutions, plan design, and build prototype.

Part 1: Brainstorming Solutions (20 minutes)

Rules for Brainstorming:

  • Come up with at least 3 different ideas
  • Quick sketches (not detailed)
  • No idea is bad in brainstorming
  • Think creatively - weird ideas okay!

Student Does:

  1. Sketch idea #1 with labels
  2. Sketch idea #2 with labels
  3. Sketch idea #3 with labels

For Each Idea:

  • How will it use magnetism?
  • What materials will it need?
  • Will it meet all criteria?

Adult Asks:

  • "Tell me about this idea - how would it work?"
  • "What's good about this design?"
  • "What might be a challenge?"
  • DON'T say which idea is best - let student evaluate

Part 2: Select and Plan (20 minutes)

Evaluate Ideas:

Student creates comparison table:

Idea | Meets Criteria? | Uses Allowed Materials? | I Can Build It? | TOTAL
#1   | ☐Yes ☐No       | ☐Yes ☐No                | ☐Yes ☐No        | _/3
#2   | ☐Yes ☐No       | ☐Yes ☐No                | ☐Yes ☐No        | _/3  
#3   | ☐Yes ☐No       | ☐Yes ☐No                | ☐Yes ☐No        | _/3

Select Best Idea:

  • Choose idea with highest score
  • OR combine features from multiple ideas
  • OR modify an idea to make it better

Create Detailed Plan:

Student draws final design with:

  • All parts labeled
  • Materials needed listed
  • How magnets will be positioned
  • Step-by-step build instructions (write 1, 2, 3...)

Materials List (student writes):

  • Magnet (how many?)
  • String (how long?)
  • [other materials...]

Part 3: Build Prototype (45-60 minutes)

Building Phase:

Student Leads Building:

  • Follows plan
  • Gathers materials one step at a time
  • Constructs design

Adult's Role:

  • Assistant, not director
  • Help with difficult tasks (cutting cardboard, holding while gluing)
  • Ask questions, don't give answers:
    • "Is that working the way you planned?"
    • "What do you want to try next?"
    • "Do you need to adjust anything?"

If Student Gets Stuck:

Adult asks:

  • "What's not working?"
  • "Why do you think that is?"
  • "What could you change?"
  • "Want to test this part before continuing?"

Encourage Problem-Solving:

  • It's okay if first try doesn't work
  • Engineers always make changes
  • Testing helps you improve

Mid-Build Testing (every 15-20 minutes):

  • Stop and test what's built so far
  • Does it work as expected?
  • Make quick adjustments
  • Continue building

Part 4: Document Build Process (10 minutes)

Student Takes:

  • Photos of design in progress
  • Photos of completed prototype
  • Notes any changes made from original plan

Write:

  • "Changes I made: ___"
  • "Why I made those changes: ___"

Session 3: Test and Improve (60-90 minutes)

Objective: Test prototype, collect data, make improvements.

Part 1: Initial Testing (25 minutes)

Test Against Each Criterion:

Student tests design and records:

Example for Retrieval Tool:

Criterion 1: Remove at least 5 washers
Test: Place 10 washers in tube, try to retrieve
Result: Retrieved ___ washers
Pass/Fail: ___
Evidence: ___

Criterion 2: Can't reach fingers in
Test: Can I solve it without using fingers?
Result: ___
Pass/Fail: ___

Criterion 3: Must use magnetic force
Test: Does design use magnetism?
Result: ___
Pass/Fail: ___

Adult Observes and Documents:

  • Take photos/video of testing
  • Record student's commentary
  • Note what works and what doesn't

Discussion After Testing:

  • "Did it meet all criteria?"
  • "What worked really well?"
  • "What didn't work as expected?"
  • "Why do you think that happened?"

Part 2: Identify Improvements (15 minutes)

Problem-Solving:

For each failed or weak criterion:

  • Student identifies: "The problem is ___"
  • Brainstorms: "I could fix it by ___"
  • Evaluates: "That would work because ___"

Create Improvement Plan:

Problem           | Possible Solution      | Why This Might Work
Magnet not strong | Use 2 magnets together | Stronger force
enough           |                        |
String too short  | Use longer string      | Can reach deeper

Select Top 2-3 Improvements:

  • Choose most important fixes
  • Plan: What exactly will you change?

Part 3: Rebuild and Improve (30-40 minutes)

Modification Phase:

Student makes improvements:

  • Follows improvement plan
  • Makes changes to prototype
  • Tests frequently as modifications are made

Document Changes:

  • Photo of each modification
  • Write: What I changed and why

Adult's Role:

  • Provide encouragement
  • Remind: Engineers rarely get it perfect first time
  • Ask: "Is this working better?"

Part 4: Final Testing (15-20 minutes)

Official Test:

Test improved design against all criteria:

  • Conduct formal test
  • Record results (measurements, observations)
  • Compare to original test results

Data Comparison:

Criterion        | Original Result | Improved Result | Better?
Remove 5 washers | Retrieved 3     | Retrieved 7     | YES! +4
[etc...]         |                 |                 |

Calculate Improvement (if measurable):

  • Original: 3 washers retrieved
  • Improved: 7 washers retrieved
  • Improvement: +4 washers (133% increase)

Session 4: Present and Reflect (30-45 minutes) - Optional

Objective: Communicate design solution and reflect on learning.

Part 1: Create Presentation (20 minutes)

Student Prepares:

  1. Display Board or Poster:

    • Title: [Name of Design]
    • Problem: What I was trying to solve
    • Solution: Photo of final design
    • How It Works: Diagram with labels
    • Results: Did it meet criteria?
  2. Engineering Notebook:

    • Organized with all sections visible
    • Original ideas
    • Build photos
    • Test data
    • Improvements
  3. Demonstration:

    • Practice showing how design works
    • Prepare to explain key features

Part 2: Present to Family (10-15 minutes)

Presentation Format:

Student explains:

  1. "The problem was..."
  2. "I used what I know about magnets to..."
  3. "Here's how my design works..." (demonstration)
  4. "My test results show..."
  5. "The improvements I made were..."
  6. "If I had more time, I would..."

Family Asks Questions:

  • Encourage genuine curiosity
  • Let student explain thinking
  • Celebrate the engineering process, not just success

Part 3: Reflection (10-15 minutes)

Student Writes (in notebook):

"Engineering Design Reflection"

  • The most challenging part was...
  • I'm most proud of...
  • What I learned about magnets that helped me:...
  • What I learned about engineering:...
  • Next time I would...
  • A new problem I want to solve:...

Discussion Questions (adult asks):

  • "How did being a scientist (learning about magnets) help you be an engineer?"
  • "What was different about engineering compared to science investigations?"
  • "When have you seen engineers solve problems in real life?"

COMPLETION CHECKLIST - Section 4

Student has completed when they have:

  • Identified chosen challenge with clear criteria and constraints
  • At least 3 brainstormed solution sketches
  • Detailed final design plan with materials list and steps
  • Built prototype following plan
  • Initial test results for all criteria documented
  • Identified specific improvements needed
  • Modified/improved prototype based on testing
  • Final test results showing comparison to initial test
  • Photos documenting build and test process
  • Presentation poster or display
  • Written reflection on engineering process
  • Can explain how magnetic force was used in solution

Time Investment:

  • Session 1: 45-60 minutes (defining problem)
  • Session 2: 90-120 minutes (design and build)
  • Session 3: 60-90 minutes (test and improve)
  • Session 4: 30-45 minutes (present and reflect) - optional
  • Total: 4-5 hours (or 5-6 hours with presentation)

OVERALL UNIT COMPLETION

Physical Science Portfolio

At unit completion, student should have:

Section 1 - Forces:

  • Data from push strength investigation
  • Graphs showing force vs. distance
  • Force diagrams (balanced and unbalanced)
  • Real-world force photos with explanations

Section 2 - Motion Patterns:

  • Position vs. time data tables
  • Motion graphs (at least 3 different patterns)
  • Prediction tests with accuracy calculations
  • Pattern documentation

Section 3 - Magnetism & Electricity:

  • Magnetic vs. non-magnetic test results
  • Pole interaction observations
  • Force-through-materials data
  • Magnet strength comparisons
  • Static electricity observations
  • Comparative analysis

Section 4 - Engineering:

  • Problem definition with criteria/constraints
  • Multiple solution sketches
  • Detailed design plan
  • Build documentation (photos)
  • Test data (initial and improved)
  • Improvement documentation
  • Final presentation

Total Time Investment

  • Section 1 (Forces): 4-5 hours
  • Section 2 (Motion): 3-4 hours
  • Section 3 (Magnetism/Electricity): 4-5 hours
  • Section 4 (Engineering): 4-6 hours

Grand Total: 15-20 hours

Recommended pace: 2-3 sessions per week = 4-6 weeks to complete


Resources Quick Reference

Primary PBS Resources Used:

  1. Force and Motion | Science Trek

  2. Balanced and Unbalanced Forces Collection

  3. Describing Motion Collection

  4. Magnets! | PBS LearningMedia

  5. Magnetic Force Collection

  6. How to Teach NGSS Engineering Design to Grades K-5

  7. Teaching NGSS Engineering Design - Elementary Collection

Additional Resources:


Parent Tips for Success

Create Supportive Learning Environment:

  • Let student lead investigations
  • Ask questions rather than give answers
  • Celebrate effort and learning, not just "right" answers
  • Allow productive struggle - don't solve problems for them

Guide Questions to Ask:

  • "What do you notice?"
  • "Why do you think that happened?"
  • "What would happen if...?"
  • "How could you test that idea?"
  • "What does your data show?"

When Student Gets Frustrated:

  • "What have you tried so far?"
  • "What's one small thing you could change?"
  • "Want to take a break and come back?"
  • "Scientists and engineers face challenges - this is normal!"

Document Learning:

  • Take photos of investigations and creations
  • Save all notebook pages and data
  • Create portfolio to show progress
  • Share with family members

Make It Fun:

  • Follow student interests for extensions
  • Connect to real-world examples they care about
  • Celebrate discoveries with enthusiasm
  • Remember: The process matters more than perfect results

End of Physical Science Guide - Home Learning Version

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can demonstrate balanced forces
  • Students can explain that balanced forces result in no change in motion
  • Students can collect data about balanced force situations

Engage (10 minutes):

  1. Tug-of-War Demonstration:

    • Two students pull rope, equal strength → rope doesn't move
    • Two students pull rope, one stronger → rope moves toward stronger student
    • Ask: "What's the difference between these situations?"
  2. Introduce Terms:

    • Balanced Forces: Equal forces in opposite directions (no motion change)
    • Unbalanced Forces: Unequal forces (motion changes)

Explore (30 minutes):

  1. Station Rotations (6 minutes per station, 5 stations):

Station 1: Book Push

  • Materials: 1 heavy book, 2 students
  • Investigation:
    • Both students push book from opposite sides with equal force
    • One student pushes harder
    • Both students stop pushing
  • Record: When did book move? When did it stay still?

Station 2: Rolling Objects

  • Materials: Ball, ramp made from book and ruler
  • Investigation:
    • Let ball roll down ramp, stop it with hand
    • Let ball roll, don't touch it
    • Push ball up ramp
  • Record: What forces acted on the ball each time?

Station 3: Balanced on Edge

  • Materials: Ruler, small objects (erasers, small toys)
  • Investigation:
    • Balance ruler on pencil (like a seesaw)
    • Add equal objects to each side
    • Add more weight to one side
  • Record: When was it balanced? How do you know?

Station 4: Sitting Still

  • Materials: Toy car on desk
  • Investigation:
    • Place car on desk, observe
    • Gently push car, then stop touching it
    • Draw diagram of forces on car when sitting still
  • Record: What forces keep car still? (gravity down, desk pushing up)

Station 5: Tug Toy

  • Materials: Toy figure or stuffed animal, 2 students
  • Investigation:
    • Both students gently pull toy in opposite directions with equal force
    • One student pulls harder
    • Both students let go
  • Record: When did toy move? When was it balanced?
  1. Rotation Management:
    • Use timer (6-minute intervals)
    • Students carry clipboards to each station
    • Materials Managers help reset stations

Explain (20 minutes):

  1. Data Sharing Circle (10 minutes):

    • Each station group shares one discovery
    • Create class chart:
      • "Balanced Forces → Object stays still OR keeps moving at same speed"
      • "Unbalanced Forces → Object starts moving, stops, or changes direction"
  2. PBS Video Clip (5 minutes):

    • Show balanced forces examples from PBS collection
    • Pause to identify: balanced or unbalanced?
  3. Science Notebook (5 minutes):

    • Students draw and label:
      • One balanced force situation
      • One unbalanced force situation
    • Caption: What's happening to the object?

Elaborate (10 minutes):

  1. Real-World Connections:
    • Brainstorm: Where do we see balanced forces?
      • Sitting in chair (gravity down, chair pushes up)
      • Book on shelf
      • Picture hanging on wall
    • For each example, identify the forces

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Quick Check:
    • Show picture of situation (person sitting, book on table, car driving)
    • Students hold up cards: "B" for balanced, "U" for unbalanced
    • Students explain reasoning to partner

Lesson 3: Investigating Unbalanced Forces (60-75 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can plan an investigation to test unbalanced forces
  • Students can measure the effects of forces on object motion
  • Students can analyze patterns in force and motion data

Engage (10 minutes):

  1. Challenge Introduction:
    • "Yesterday we found that balanced forces don't change motion. What about UNbalanced forces?"
    • Demo: Push toy car gently, then harder
    • Ask: "What changed? What stayed the same?"

Explore (35 minutes):

  1. Investigation Planning (10 minutes):

    • Question: "How does the strength of a push affect how far an object moves?"
    • As a class, plan investigation:
      • What will we test? (toy car on floor)
      • What will we change? (strength of push: gentle, medium, hard)
      • What will we measure? (distance traveled)
      • How will we keep it fair? (same car, same floor, same starting place)
  2. Creating Investigation Protocol:

    • Students help write steps:
      1. Mark starting line with tape
      2. Place car at line
      3. Gentle push - measure distance
      4. Repeat 3 times (medium push, hard push)
      5. Record data in table
  3. Conducting Investigation (25 minutes):

    • Pairs conduct investigation:
      • 3 trials per push strength
      • Measure in inches or centimeters
      • Record in data table

Data Table Template:

Push Strength | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Average
Gentle        |         |         |         |
Medium        |         |         |         |
Hard          |         |         |         |

Explain (15 minutes):

  1. Data Analysis (10 minutes):

    • Partners calculate averages
    • Create bar graph showing results
    • Compare results with another pair
    • Discuss: "What patterns do you notice?"
  2. Class Discussion (5 minutes):

    • Share findings: "What happened when we pushed harder?"
    • Conclusion: "Bigger force → bigger change in motion"
    • Record on class anchor chart

Elaborate (10 minutes):

  1. Extension Investigation:
    • "What if we changed the ramp height?"
    • Set up ramps with books (1 book, 2 books, 3 books)
    • Students predict: Which will make car go farther?
    • Quick test and measure
    • Connect: Steeper ramp = more force from gravity

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Claim-Evidence-Reasoning:
    • Students write:
      • Claim: How does push strength affect motion?
      • Evidence: What data supports your claim?
      • Reasoning: Why does this happen?

PRACTICE (1-2 hours)

Practice Activity 1: Force Investigations (45-60 minutes)

Independent Practice:

Students design and conduct their own force investigation:

Investigation Options:

  1. Ramp Angles:

    • Question: How does ramp steepness affect speed?
    • Materials: Books, ruler for ramp, toy car, stopwatch
    • Variables: Number of books (1, 2, 3, 4)
    • Measure: Time to roll down
  2. Surface Friction:

    • Question: Do different surfaces change how far objects slide?
    • Materials: Toy car, different surfaces (smooth floor, carpet, sandpaper, wax paper)
    • Variables: Surface type
    • Measure: Distance traveled with same push
  3. Object Mass:

    • Question: Does object weight affect motion with same push?
    • Materials: Empty box, same box with books inside, standard push technique
    • Variables: Weight of object
    • Measure: Distance traveled
  4. Ball Bounce:

    • Question: Do bigger forces create bigger bounces?
    • Materials: Ball, measuring tape, different drop heights
    • Variables: Drop height (force from gravity)
    • Measure: Bounce height

Student Work Process:

  1. Choose Investigation (5 minutes):

    • Select from options above or propose own (with teacher approval)
    • Write question on investigation sheet
  2. Plan (10 minutes):

    • List materials needed
    • Identify variables:
      • What will change? (independent variable)
      • What will be measured? (dependent variable)
      • What stays the same? (controlled variables)
    • Write step-by-step procedure
  3. Conduct (20 minutes):

    • Follow procedure
    • Collect data (at least 3 trials)
    • Record observations
  4. Analyze (10 minutes):

    • Calculate averages
    • Create graph
    • Write conclusion
  5. Share (10 minutes):

    • Partner presentations
    • Display posters/data in classroom

Scaffolds for Different Learners:

  • Emerging: Provide structured investigation sheet with blanks to fill
  • Developing: Offer choice of 2-3 pre-designed investigations
  • Advanced: Design completely original investigation

Practice Activity 2: Forces in Action Scenarios (30 minutes)

Differentiated Practice:

Students apply force concepts to real-world scenarios:

Scenario Cards (create 8-10):

  1. Playground Swing:

    • Question: What forces act on a swing? When are they balanced? Unbalanced?
    • Task: Draw diagram with force arrows, explain motion
  2. Soccer Ball Kick:

    • Question: What happens when you kick a ball harder vs. softer?
    • Task: Predict distances, explain using force concepts
  3. Pushing a Shopping Cart:

    • Question: Why is an empty cart easier to push than a full one?
    • Task: Compare forces needed, draw diagrams
  4. Sliding Down a Slide:

    • Question: What makes you speed up going down?
    • Task: Identify forces, explain motion changes
  5. Riding a Bike:

    • Question: What forces act when you pedal? When you brake?
    • Task: Create before/after diagrams

Activity Structure:

  • Small groups (3-4 students) get 2-3 scenario cards
  • 8 minutes per scenario
  • Create poster explaining forces and motion
  • Gallery walk to see other groups' work

Practice Activity 3: Forces Assessment Portfolio (30 minutes)

Summative Assessment:

Students create portfolio demonstrating understanding:

Portfolio Components:

  1. Investigation Report (from Activity 1):

    • Question, procedure, data, graph, conclusion
  2. Force Diagrams (3 examples):

    • Object at rest (balanced forces)
    • Object starting to move (unbalanced forces)
    • Object stopping (unbalanced forces)
    • Arrows show direction and relative strength of forces
  3. Everyday Forces Photo Journal:

    • Students take/find 5 photos showing forces
    • Label each photo:
      • What forces are acting?
      • Are they balanced or unbalanced?
      • How do you know?
  4. Reflection:

    • "What I learned about forces and motion..."
    • "One question I still have is..."
    • "I can use this knowledge to..."

Rubric:

Criteria Developing Proficient Advanced
Investigation Incomplete data or unclear procedure Complete data with clear procedure and graph Multiple trials, detailed analysis, identifies sources of error
Force Diagrams Missing elements or incorrect arrows All forces labeled with correct directions Proportional arrows showing relative force strength
Photo Journal Fewer than 5 examples or minimal explanation 5 examples with correct force identification Creative examples with detailed scientific explanation
Reflection Brief or unclear Thoughtful with specific examples Makes connections beyond classroom

Section 2: Motion Patterns

Standard: 3-PS2-2
Time: 3-4 hours

Performance Expectation

Make observations and/or measurements of an object's motion to provide evidence that a pattern can be used to predict future motion.


SETUP (30 minutes total)

Teacher Prep (10 minutes)

Before the Lesson:

  1. Review PBS Resources:

  2. Create Measurement Tools:

    • Print or create graphing templates:
      • Position vs. Time graphs (blank)
      • Distance traveled charts
    • Prepare example graphs to model
  3. Prepare Prediction Challenges:

    • Set up demonstration area with clear sightlines
    • Test equipment to ensure predictable motion

Materials to Prepare:

  • Stopwatches or timers (1 per group)
  • Measuring tapes or meter sticks
  • Masking tape for marking positions
  • Toy cars, balls, or rolling objects
  • Ramps (books + rulers)

Student Prep (20 minutes)

Student Tasks:

  1. Measurement Station Setup (10 minutes):

    • Students use masking tape to create measurement lines:
      • Starting line (0)
      • Lines every 10 cm or 6 inches for 1-2 meters
      • Label each line with distance
    • Create at least 3 measurement tracks in classroom
  2. Tool Organization (5 minutes):

    • Distribute stopwatches/timers
    • Practice starting and stopping timers
    • Practice reading time to nearest second
  3. Data Sheet Prep (5 minutes):

    • Students create data tables from teacher template:

Position Recording Sheet:

Time (seconds) | Position (distance from start)
0              |
1              |
2              |
3              |
4              |
5              |

INSTRUCTION (1.5 hours)

Lesson 1: Observing and Measuring Motion (45 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can describe object motion using position and time
  • Students can measure and record object position over time
  • Students can identify patterns in motion

Engage (8 minutes):

  1. Mystery Motion:

    • Teacher walks across room at steady pace
    • Students close eyes
    • Ask: "Where will I be in 5 more seconds?"
    • Reveal: Keep walking, check prediction
    • Discuss: "How did you know?"
  2. Introduce Concept:

    • "When motion follows a pattern, we can predict where objects will be"
    • Today's goal: Find patterns in motion

Explore (20 minutes):

  1. Rolling Car Investigation:

    • Groups get: toy car, ramp, measuring track, stopwatch
    • Task: Record where car is every second for 5 seconds
    • Procedure:
      • Student 1: Releases car at "Go"
      • Student 2: Calls time every second (1, 2, 3, 4, 5)
      • Student 3: Marks car position at each number
      • Student 4: Records distances in table
  2. Data Collection:

    • Conduct 2-3 trials
    • Record position at each time point
    • Notice: Does car move same amount each second?

Explain (12 minutes):

  1. Graphing Motion (7 minutes):

    • Model creating position vs. time graph:
      • X-axis: Time (seconds)
      • Y-axis: Position (distance from start)
      • Plot points from data
      • Connect points
    • Students create their own graphs
  2. Pattern Analysis (5 minutes):

    • "What does your graph show?"
    • Identify patterns:
      • Straight line = steady speed
      • Curve = speeding up or slowing down
    • Compare graphs between groups

Elaborate (5 minutes):

  1. Make Predictions:
    • "Based on your pattern, where would the car be at 6 seconds? 7 seconds?"
    • Students extend their graphs to predict
    • Quick test: Does prediction match reality?

Evaluate (Quick Check):

  1. Partners Quiz:
    • Student A describes motion pattern
    • Student B predicts next position
    • Switch roles

Lesson 2: Using Patterns to Predict (45 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can use motion patterns to make predictions
  • Students can test and revise predictions
  • Students can explain how patterns help predict motion

Engage (7 minutes):

  1. Pendulum Demo:
    • Create simple pendulum (string + weight)
    • Release and let swing
    • Ask: "Will it swing the same way every time?"
    • Observe: Yes! It follows a pattern

Explore (25 minutes):

  1. Prediction Challenges - 3 stations, 8 minutes each:

Station 1: Ball Roll Prediction

  • Setup: Ball rolling down ramp
  • Task:
    • Roll ball, measure position at 1, 2, 3 seconds
    • Create quick graph
    • Predict: Where will it be at 4 seconds?
    • Test prediction, measure accuracy

Station 2: Pendulum Swing

  • Setup: String with washer or weight
  • Task:
    • Count swings in 10 seconds (3 trials)
    • Find average
    • Predict: How many swings in 30 seconds?
    • Test prediction

Station 3: Wind-Up Toy

  • Setup: Wind-up toy on marked track
  • Task:
    • Wind same number of turns each time
    • Measure distance traveled (3 trials)
    • Predict: Distance for 4th trial
    • Calculate percent error

Percent Error Formula (for advanced students):

Error = |Predicted - Actual| ÷ Actual × 100%

Explain (8 minutes):

  1. Pattern Discussion:

    • Each station shares:
      • What pattern did you find?
      • How accurate was your prediction?
      • What made predicting easy or hard?
  2. Key Concepts:

    • "Regular, repeated motion is predictable"
    • "The more data we have, the better our predictions"
    • "Patterns help us know what will happen next"

Elaborate (5 minutes):

  1. Real-World Patterns:
    • Brainstorm predictable motions:
      • Clock hands
      • Sunrise/sunset times
      • Seasons
      • Tides
    • Discuss: Why are patterns useful?

PRACTICE (1-2 hours)

Practice Activity 1: Motion Pattern Projects (60 minutes)

Project Options (students choose one):

Option A: Ramp Speed Investigation

  • Question: How does ramp angle affect car speed pattern?
  • Procedure:
    • Set up 3 ramps (low, medium, steep angles)
    • Release car, record time to travel same distance
    • Create 3 graphs (position vs. time for each angle)
    • Compare: Which shows fastest motion? How can you tell from graph?

Option B: Bounce Pattern Study

  • Question: Do balls bounce in predictable patterns?
  • Procedure:
    • Drop ball from same height 5 times
    • Measure first bounce height each time
    • Calculate average bounce height
    • Predict 6th bounce, test
    • Graph: Drop height vs. Bounce height for different heights

Option C: Swing Investigation

  • Question: Does pendulum length affect swing pattern?
  • Procedure:
    • Create pendulums: 20cm, 40cm, 60cm string lengths
    • Count swings in 30 seconds for each
    • Record data for 3 trials each
    • Graph: Length vs. Swings per minute
    • Predict: How many swings for 80cm pendulum?

Project Requirements:

  1. Clear question
  2. Data table with at least 3 trials
  3. Graph showing pattern
  4. Written prediction based on pattern
  5. Test of prediction with accuracy check

Timeline:

  • Planning: 10 minutes
  • Data collection: 25 minutes
  • Analysis and graphing: 15 minutes
  • Prediction and testing: 10 minutes

Practice Activity 2: Motion Detective (30 minutes)

Activity Description: Students analyze motion graphs and descriptions to identify patterns and make predictions.

Task Cards (create 6-8):

Card 1: Mystery Walker

  • Provides: Graph showing position increasing steadily over time
  • Questions:
    • What kind of motion does this show?
    • Is the object speeding up, slowing down, or steady?
    • Predict position at 10 seconds
    • Draw what this motion might look like

Card 2: Race Cars

  • Provides: Two graphs on same axes (Car A and Car B)
  • Questions:
    • Which car is faster? How do you know?
    • Which car will reach 100m first?
    • At what time are they at the same position?

Card 3: Bouncing Ball

  • Provides: Description of ball bouncing lower each time
  • Questions:
    • Sketch graph of bounce height vs. bounce number
    • Predict: Will it keep bouncing forever? Why/why not?
    • Describe the pattern

Card 4: Bike Ride

  • Provides: Story - "I rode my bike at 2 meters per second for 10 seconds"
  • Questions:
    • Create data table showing position every 2 seconds
    • Graph the motion
    • Where was I at 5 seconds?

Activity Structure:

  • Partners work through 3-4 cards
  • Rotate cards every 7-8 minutes
  • Discussion: Share strategies for finding patterns

Practice Activity 3: Predict and Verify Challenge (30 minutes)

Challenge Format:

Students use motion patterns to make precise predictions in real-time challenges.

Setup:

  • Create 4 challenge stations
  • Groups rotate (7 minutes per station)

Challenge 1: Target Practice

  • Given: Toy car, ramp, target zone marked on floor
  • Task:
    • Find pattern - how far does car roll from different ramp heights?
    • Predict ramp height needed to reach target
    • Test prediction
    • Adjust if needed

Challenge 2: Timer Task

  • Given: Ball rolling down ramp
  • Task:
    • Find pattern - how long to roll specific distances?
    • Predict how far ball will roll in exactly 3 seconds
    • Mark prediction on floor
    • Test and measure accuracy

Challenge 3: Catch the Car

  • Given: Toy car, measurement track
  • Task:
    • Find car's speed pattern
    • Predict where car will be in 5 seconds
    • Stand at that spot to "catch" it
    • How close were you?

Challenge 4: Pendulum Count

  • Given: Pendulum
  • Task:
    • Find pattern - swings per 10 seconds
    • Predict total swings in 1 minute
    • Count to verify
    • Calculate accuracy

Scoring:

  • Points for accuracy: Within 5% = 3 pts, 10% = 2 pts, 20% = 1 pt
  • Track team scores
  • Discuss: What strategies helped you make good predictions?

Section 3: Magnetic and Electric Forces

Standard: 3-PS2-3
Time: 4-5 hours

Performance Expectation

Ask questions to determine cause and effect relationships of electric or magnetic interactions between two objects not in contact with each other.


SETUP (1 hour total)

Teacher Prep (20 minutes)

Before the Unit:

  1. Review PBS Resources:

  2. Safety Preparation:

    • Critical: Review magnet safety
    • Check for students with pacemakers or medical devices
    • Establish "keep magnets away from electronics" rule
    • Prepare static electricity safety guidelines

Safety Guidelines:

MAGNET AND ELECTRICITY SAFETY
1. Never put magnets near computers, phones, or tablets
2. Keep magnets away from credit cards or ID badges
3. Small magnets are choking hazards - no mouth contact
4. Report any broken magnets immediately
5. For static electricity: Small sparks are normal and safe
6. Tell teacher if you have medical devices
  1. Organize Materials:
    • Test all magnets (mark poles with stickers: R for red/north, B for blue/south)
    • Sort magnetic vs. non-magnetic items
    • Prepare static electricity materials
    • Create investigation kits for each group

Student Prep (40 minutes)

Student Tasks:

  1. Magnet Organization (20 minutes):

    • Students sort and label:
      • Magnetic Items Bin: Paper clips, steel washers, screws, nails, scissors (metal)
      • Non-Magnetic Items Bin: Plastic clips, pennies, aluminum foil, rubber bands, wooden items, paper
      • Magnet Kit: Bar magnets (2), horseshoe magnets (2), magnetic wand, magnetic marbles
    • Label each bin clearly
    • Create inventory checklist
  2. Exploration Station Setup (15 minutes):

    • Students set up 5 stations:
      • Station 1: Magnets + magnetic items
      • Station 2: Magnets + non-magnetic items
      • Station 3: Magnet interaction (2 magnets)
      • Station 4: Static electricity (balloons, paper scraps, plastic)
      • Station 5: Mystery boxes (hidden magnets inside)
  3. Question Recording Sheets (5 minutes):

    • Students prepare investigation notebooks:
      • "I wonder..." section for questions
      • "I observed..." section for findings
      • "This happened because..." section for explanations

Materials Checklist:

MAGNETS:
□ Bar magnets (8-12, poles labeled)
□ Horseshoe magnets (4-6)
□ Magnetic wands (4-6)
□ Donut magnets (10-15)
□ Small magnetic marbles (optional)

MAGNETIC ITEMS:
□ Paper clips (100+)
□ Steel washers (30-40)
□ Iron nails (20-30)
□ Metal screws (20-30)
□ Steel wool (small amount)
□ Scissors with metal (4-6)

NON-MAGNETIC ITEMS:
□ Plastic items (clips, rulers, toys)
□ Pennies (post-1982, mostly zinc)
□ Aluminum foil
□ Rubber bands
□ Wooden blocks
□ Paper, cardboard
□ Glass marbles
□ Brass fasteners

STATIC ELECTRICITY:
□ Balloons (12-15)
□ Wool cloth or sweaters
□ Plastic combs (6-8)
□ Tissue paper scraps
□ Puffed rice cereal
□ Plastic straws (cut in pieces)

INSTRUCTION (2 hours)

Lesson 1: Discovering Magnetic Forces (60 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can identify magnetic vs. non-magnetic materials
  • Students can describe magnetic attraction and repulsion
  • Students can ask questions about magnetic interactions

Engage (10 minutes):

  1. Mystery Force Demo:

    • Place paper clip on desk
    • Hold magnet underneath desk, move it
    • Paper clip moves without being touched!
    • Ask: "How is this possible? What's happening?"
  2. Generate Questions:

    • Students brainstorm questions about magnets
    • Record on class chart: "What We Wonder About Magnets"
    • Examples:
      • What can magnets stick to?
      • How do magnets work through materials?
      • Can magnets push away from each other?

Explore (30 minutes):

  1. Free Exploration (15 minutes):

    • Groups get magnet kit and bins of items
    • Open-ended exploration: "What can you discover about magnets?"
    • Students record observations and new questions
    • Encourage testing ideas:
      • What sticks to magnets?
      • Do magnets work through paper? Cardboard? Hands?
      • What happens with two magnets?
  2. Focused Investigation (15 minutes):

    • Magnetic vs. Non-Magnetic Test:

      • Test each item in bins
      • Create two-column chart: "Magnetic" vs. "Not Magnetic"
      • Look for patterns: What do magnetic items have in common?
    • Magnet Interactions:

      • Bring two magnets close together
      • Try different orientations
      • Observe: Sometimes attract, sometimes repel
      • Mark which ends attract and which repel

Explain (15 minutes):

  1. PBS Video (8 minutes):

    • Watch "Magnets!" from PBS LearningMedia
    • Pause to discuss key concepts:
      • Magnets attract iron and steel
      • Magnets have two poles (north and south)
      • Opposite poles attract, same poles repel
  2. Vocabulary (7 minutes):

    • Attract: Pull objects toward magnet
    • Repel: Push objects away from magnet
    • Magnetic: Materials that magnets can attract (iron, steel, nickel, cobalt)
    • Poles: Two ends of magnet (north and south)
    • Add to word wall with diagrams

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Quick Assessment:
    • Show various items
    • Students predict: Magnetic or not?
    • Test to verify
    • Students explain reasoning

Lesson 2: Investigating Magnetic Force at a Distance (60 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can demonstrate that magnets exert force without touching
  • Students can investigate how distance affects magnetic force
  • Students can explain cause and effect in magnetic interactions

Engage (8 minutes):

  1. Challenge:
    • "Can a magnet move something without touching it?"
    • Demo: Magnet under paper moves paper clip on top
    • Question: "How far away can the magnet be and still work?"

Explore (30 minutes):

  1. Distance Investigation (20 minutes):
    • Question: "How many sheets of paper can magnetic force work through?"

    • Procedure:

      • Place paper clip on desk
      • Hold magnet underneath 1 sheet of paper
      • Does clip move?
      • Add papers one at a time
      • Record: Maximum number of papers
    • Data collection:

      • Test with different magnet strengths
      • Test with cardboard, plastic, wood
      • Record findings in table

Data Table:

Material Between | Number of Layers | Did Magnet Work?
Paper           | 1                |
Paper           | 2                |
Paper           | 5                |
Cardboard       | 1                |
Plastic         | 1                |
Wood            | 1                |
  1. Strength Test (10 minutes):
    • "Which magnet is strongest?"
    • Test: How many paper clips can each magnet hold?
    • Create paper clip chain
    • Record: Max number before chain breaks

Explain (17 minutes):

  1. Data Analysis (7 minutes):

    • Share results
    • Pattern: Magnetic force works through non-magnetic materials
    • Pattern: Force gets weaker with distance
    • Pattern: Stronger magnets work through more layers
  2. Cause and Effect (10 minutes):

    • Create cause-effect chart:

      • Cause: Bring magnet close to paper clip
      • Effect: Paper clip moves toward magnet
      • Explanation: Magnetic force pulls even without touching
    • Practice with other examples:

      • Cause: Put paper between magnet and clip → Effect: Still works
      • Cause: Use stronger magnet → Effect: Works through more layers
      • Cause: Move magnet farther away → Effect: Force gets weaker

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Exit Ticket:
    • Draw diagram showing magnet force through material
    • Label: Magnet, object, material in between, force arrows
    • Explain: Why does it work without touching?

Lesson 3: Electric Forces and Static Electricity (60 minutes - optional/simplified)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can demonstrate electric force interactions
  • Students can compare electric and magnetic forces
  • Students can ask questions about electric forces

Note: This lesson is simplified for 3rd grade. Full understanding of electricity is typically 4th-5th grade content.

Engage (10 minutes):

  1. Static Electricity Demo:

    • Rub balloon on wool or hair (15-20 times)
    • Hold near paper scraps - they jump to balloon!
    • Ask: "Is this magnetism? What's different?"
  2. Compare:

    • Try: Does balloon attract paper clips like magnet?
    • Observe: Different force - only works on light objects
    • Introduce: This is electric force

Explore (25 minutes):

  1. Static Electricity Stations (10 minutes per station):

Station 1: Balloon Attraction

  • Rub balloon on hair/wool
  • Hold near: tissue paper bits, puffed rice, hair, water stream
  • Record: What gets attracted? How long does it last?

Station 2: Plastic Comb

  • Rub plastic comb on hair/wool
  • Hold near paper scraps
  • Observe attraction
  • Question: Is this the same as balloon?

Station 3: Repulsion Test

  • Rub two balloons on hair
  • Bring them close together
  • Observe: They push apart!
  • Compare: Like magnetic repulsion?

Explain (20 minutes):

  1. Compare Forces (15 minutes):
    • Create Venn diagram: Magnetic Forces vs. Electric Forces

Similarities:

  • Both work without touching
  • Both can attract AND repel
  • Both get weaker with distance
  • Both are invisible

Differences:

  • Magnets: Work on iron/steel only, always work
  • Static electricity: Works on many materials, temporary
  1. Vocabulary (5 minutes):
    • Static Electricity: Electric force that builds up
    • Attract: Pull together (both forces)
    • Repel: Push apart (both forces)

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Compare and Contrast:
    • Show demonstration
    • Students identify: Magnetic or electric force?
    • Explain: How do you know?

PRACTICE (1-2 hours)

Practice Activity 1: Magnetic Force Investigations (45 minutes)

Independent Investigations (students choose):

Investigation A: Magnet Maze

  • Design: Create maze on paper
  • Challenge: Move paper clip through maze using magnet underneath
  • Questions:
    • What makes this work?
    • Can you make maze harder? How?
    • What happens if you add more paper layers?

Investigation B: Magnet Strength Comparison

  • Test: Different magnets
  • Method: Count paper clips each can hold in chain
  • Graph: Bar graph comparing magnet strengths
  • Questions:
    • Which magnet is strongest?
    • Does size predict strength?
    • How could you make a stronger magnet?

Investigation C: Force Through Materials

  • Test: Magnetic force through different materials (paper, cardboard, plastic, aluminum, wood)
  • Method: Stack different materials, test how many layers block force
  • Data: Create table comparing materials
  • Questions:
    • Which materials block magnetic force best?
    • Are any materials completely blocking? Why/why not?

Investigation D: Repulsion Race

  • Setup: Donut magnets on pencil or straw
  • Challenge: Stack magnets with same poles facing (they repel and float)
  • Question: How many can you stack before they flip?
  • Extension: Race floating magnet by pushing with another magnet

Work Time:

  • Planning: 5 minutes
  • Investigation: 25 minutes
  • Recording: 10 minutes
  • Sharing: 5 minutes

Practice Activity 2: Magnetic Questions and Answers (30 minutes)

Scientific Questioning Practice:

Students develop and test scientific questions about magnetic forces.

Question Starters (post these):

  • "What happens when..."
  • "How does _____ affect _____?"
  • "Why does..."
  • "What would happen if..."

Process:

  1. Generate Questions (10 minutes):
    • Individually, write 3 questions about magnets
    • Share with partner
    • Choose best question together
    • Question must be testable with available materials

Quality Question Checklist:

  • Can be tested with our materials
  • Has a clear cause and effect
  • We can measure or observe the answer
  • It's not just yes/no (asks "how" or "why")
  1. Plan Investigation (5 minutes):

    • Write hypothesis (prediction with reason)
    • List materials needed
    • Outline steps to test
  2. Conduct Test (10 minutes):

    • Follow plan
    • Record observations
    • Collect data
  3. Share Findings (5 minutes):

    • Partner pairs share questions and answers
    • Class discusses most interesting discoveries

Example Questions Students Might Ask:

  • "How does the shape of a magnet affect its strength?"
  • "What happens when you break a magnet in half?"
  • "Can you make a temporary magnet by rubbing iron with a magnet?"
  • "How does temperature affect magnetic force?" (requires ice/heat source)

Practice Activity 3: Forces Museum (45 minutes)

Culminating Activity:

Students create museum exhibits demonstrating magnetic or electric forces.

Exhibit Requirements:

  1. Interactive Demonstration:

    • Shows magnetic or electric force in action
    • Visitors can participate safely
    • Clearly demonstrates cause and effect
  2. Explanation Sign:

    • Title of exhibit
    • What's happening? (description)
    • Why it works (scientific explanation)
    • "Try it yourself" instructions
  3. Question for Visitors:

    • Thought-provoking question about the exhibit
    • Visitors write answers on sticky notes

Exhibit Ideas:

  • Magnetic Attraction Gallery: Multiple examples of magnetic attraction through different materials
  • Repulsion Station: Demonstrations of magnetic repulsion
  • Strength Test Center: Compare different magnet strengths
  • Invisible Force Exhibit: Shows force working through barriers
  • Static Electricity Corner: Multiple static electricity demonstrations
  • Force Comparison Display: Side-by-side magnetic and electric forces

Timeline:

  • Design and build: 20 minutes
  • Create signs: 10 minutes
  • Museum walk: 10 minutes (students visit 3-4 exhibits)
  • Discussion: 5 minutes

Assessment:

  • Peer feedback: What did you learn from other exhibits?
  • Teacher checklist: Accurate science? Clear explanation? Engaging demonstration?

Section 4: Engineering Design with Magnets

Standard: 3-PS2-4
Time: 4-5 hours

Performance Expectation

Define a simple design problem that can be solved by applying scientific ideas about magnets.


SETUP (1 hour total)

Teacher Prep (20 minutes)

Before the Unit:

  1. Review Engineering Resources:

    • Watch PBS "Teaching NGSS Engineering Design" video
    • Review constraint examples from real engineering
    • Prepare design challenge materials
  2. Set Up Design Problem:

    • Choose 1-2 design challenges (see options below)
    • Gather materials for each challenge
    • Create criteria and constraint cards
    • Prepare testing protocols
  3. Create Assessment Tools:

    • Design notebook templates
    • Rubric for engineering process
    • Peer feedback forms

Engineering Vocabulary to Pre-Teach:

  • Design: Plan for how to make something
  • Criteria: Requirements the solution must meet (what it needs to do)
  • Constraints: Limitations on the solution (what you can't do/use)
  • Prototype: First model or version to test
  • Iterate: Improve design based on testing

Student Prep (40 minutes)

Student Tasks:

  1. Materials Organization (25 minutes):

    • Sort building materials into labeled bins:
      • Magnets Bin: Various magnets (bar, donut, wand)
      • Structure Materials: Cardboard, straws, popsicle sticks, cups, tubes
      • Fasteners: Tape, glue, string, rubber bands, paper clips
      • Testing Materials: Paper clips, washers, small objects
    • Create material checkout system
    • Count and inventory all supplies
  2. Design Workspace Setup (10 minutes):

    • Clear large work areas
    • Set up testing zones
    • Create material distribution area
    • Prepare cleanup stations
  3. Engineering Notebook Prep (5 minutes):

    • Students prepare design notebooks with sections:
      • Problem definition
      • Brainstorm sketches
      • Final design plan
      • Testing results
      • Improvements

Materials Checklist for Design Challenges:

MAGNETS:
□ Bar magnets (12-15)
□ Donut magnets (20-30)
□ Small circular magnets (30-40)
□ Magnetic strips (if available)

BUILDING MATERIALS:
□ Cardboard pieces (various sizes)
□ Toilet paper/paper towel tubes (12-15)
□ Popsicle sticks (100+)
□ Plastic straws (50+)
□ Small paper/plastic cups (20-30)
□ String/yarn
□ Pipe cleaners (50+)

FASTENERS:
□ Masking tape (4-6 rolls)
□ Clear tape
□ Glue sticks (12-15)
□ Rubber bands (various sizes)
□ Paper clips (100+)

TESTING MATERIALS:
□ Metal washers (30-40)
□ Small toys or blocks
□ Timers/stopwatches
□ Rulers/measuring tapes
□ Balance scale (if available)

INSTRUCTION (1.5 hours)

Lesson 1: Defining Engineering Problems (45 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can identify criteria and constraints for a design problem
  • Students can explain how scientific knowledge helps solve problems
  • Students can develop multiple solutions to a problem

Engage (10 minutes):

  1. Real-World Problem:

    • Show video or images of:
      • Refrigerator magnets holding papers
      • Magnetic cabinet latches
      • Magnetic toys
      • MRI machines (simplified)
    • Ask: "How are magnets used to solve problems?"
  2. Engineering vs. Science:

    • Science: Understanding how magnets work
    • Engineering: Using that knowledge to solve problems
    • Today: Be engineers!

Explore (20 minutes):

  1. Analyze Existing Design (10 minutes):

    • Show: Simple magnetic paper clip holder
    • Identify together:
      • Problem it solves: Need to organize paper clips
      • How it works: Magnetic attraction holds clips
      • Criteria (what it must do):
        • Hold at least 10 paper clips
        • Easy to add and remove clips
        • Stays on desk without falling
      • Constraints (limitations):
        • Must use only 1 magnet
        • Must be smaller than a book
        • Can't use glue that takes days to dry
  2. Practice Identifying (10 minutes):

    • Present problem: "Design a magnetic toy that moves without touching it"
    • Small groups identify:
      • What must the toy do? (criteria)
      • What are the limitations? (constraints)
    • Share with class
    • Teacher models recording in organized format

Criteria and Constraints Template:

PROBLEM: ________________________________

CRITERIA (What it must do):
1. 
2. 
3. 

CONSTRAINTS (Limitations):
- Materials: 
- Size: 
- Time: 
- Cost: 

Explain (10 minutes):

  1. Engineering Design Process:

    • Introduce 5-step process (simplified):
      1. Ask: What's the problem? What are criteria and constraints?
      2. Imagine: Brainstorm many solutions
      3. Plan: Choose best idea, make detailed plan
      4. Create: Build prototype
      5. Improve: Test and make it better
  2. Why Criteria and Constraints Matter:

    • Criteria = success measures
    • Constraints = realistic limits (time, money, materials, safety)
    • Real engineers always have both

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Quick Check:
    • Show simple problem
    • Students list 2 criteria and 2 constraints
    • Share with partner

Lesson 2: Brainstorming and Planning Solutions (45 minutes)

Learning Objectives:

  • Students can generate multiple solutions to a design problem
  • Students can select a solution based on criteria and constraints
  • Students can create detailed plans for their designs

Engage (5 minutes):

  1. Design Challenge Introduction:
    • Present ONE challenge (teacher choice):

Challenge Option A: Magnetic Retrieval Tool

  • Problem: Small metal objects (washers) have fallen into a tall, narrow tube. How can you get them out without reaching in?
  • Criteria:
    • Must remove at least 5 washers
    • Can't reach fingers into tube
    • Must use magnetic force
  • Constraints:
    • Can use: 1-2 magnets, string, tape, popsicle sticks, straws
    • 30 minutes to build
    • Tool must be no wider than tube opening

Challenge Option B: Magnetic Maze Game

  • Problem: Design a game where player moves object through maze without touching it
  • Criteria:
    • Object must navigate complete maze
    • Controlled by player using magnet
    • Game has clear start and finish
  • Constraints:
    • Materials: Cardboard, 1-2 magnets, paper clips, markers
    • Maze size: No larger than one sheet of cardboard
    • Must work through cardboard thickness

Challenge Option C: Magnetic Separator

  • Problem: Mixed pile of magnetic and non-magnetic objects needs to be sorted quickly
  • Criteria:
    • Separates all magnetic items in under 2 minutes
    • Doesn't require touching each object individually
    • Magnetic items collected in one container
  • Constraints:
    • Can use: Magnets, containers, any fasteners
    • Must be operated by one person
    • Must be reusable

Explore (25 minutes):

  1. Brainstorm Phase (10 minutes):
    • Rule: Quantity over quality - get all ideas out
    • Partners sketch at least 3 different solutions
    • No criticism allowed during brainstorming
    • Quick sketches with labels, not detailed

Brainstorm Tips (post these):

  • Think about what you learned about magnets
  • Look at the materials available
  • Consider: How will magnetic force solve the problem?
  • Different is good!
  1. Compare and Select (10 minutes):

    • For each brainstorm sketch, evaluate:
      • Does it meet all criteria?
      • Can we build it with allowed materials?
      • Will magnetic force work as planned?
    • Rate each idea: 1 (weak) to 3 (strong)
    • Choose best idea or combine features
  2. Detailed Planning (5 minutes):

    • Create final design plan with:
      • Labeled diagram
      • Materials list
      • Step-by-step build instructions
      • Prediction: How well will it work?

Explain (10 minutes):

  1. Design Presentations (7 minutes):

    • 3-4 teams share plans (1-2 minutes each)
    • Class asks clarifying questions
    • Feedback: Will it meet criteria? Any concerns?
  2. Refine Plans (3 minutes):

    • Based on feedback, make quick adjustments
    • Teacher checks plans before building phase

Evaluate (5 minutes):

  1. Plan Check:
    • Students self-assess using checklist:
      • Clear diagram with labels
      • Shows how magnets will be used
      • Materials list matches constraints
      • Addresses all criteria

PRACTICE (2-3 hours)

Practice Activity 1: Build and Test Prototypes (90 minutes)

Building Phase (60 minutes):

  1. Materials Checkout (5 minutes):

    • Teams gather materials from bins
    • Record what they take on checkout sheet
    • Return any items they decide not to use
  2. Construction (45 minutes):

    • Teams build following their plans
    • Teacher circulates:
      • Ask questions: "How does this part work?"
      • Encourage problem-solving: "What could you try differently?"
      • Monitor safety and material use

Teacher Facilitation Questions:

  • "How are you using what you learned about magnetic force?"
  • "What's working well? What's challenging?"
  • "How does this meet your criteria?"
  • "What would you do differently if you started over?"
  1. Mid-Build Check (10 minutes):
    • Pause construction
    • Quick test of current design
    • Identify problems
    • Decide: Continue as planned or modify?

Testing Phase (30 minutes):

  1. Initial Testing (15 minutes):
    • Test prototype against each criterion
    • Record results in engineering notebook:

Testing Template:

Criterion 1: _______ | Result: Pass/Fail | Evidence:
Criterion 2: _______ | Result: Pass/Fail | Evidence:
Criterion 3: _______ | Result: Pass/Fail | Evidence:

What worked well:
What didn't work:
Ideas for improvement:
  1. Peer Testing (10 minutes):

    • Switch with another team
    • Test each other's designs
    • Provide feedback:
      • What impressed you?
      • What suggestions do you have?
  2. Testing Debrief (5 minutes):

    • Class discussion:
      • How many designs met all criteria?
      • What was the hardest part?
      • What magnetic force concepts were most important?

Practice Activity 2: Iterate and Improve (60 minutes)

Improvement Phase:

  1. Analyze Failures (10 minutes):

    • Review testing results
    • Identify specific problems:
      • Magnet not strong enough?
      • Structure unstable?
      • Difficult to control?
    • Brainstorm: What could fix each problem?
  2. Plan Improvements (10 minutes):

    • Sketch modifications on original design
    • List specific changes to make:
      • Add, remove, or change materials
      • Adjust magnet position
      • Strengthen structure
    • Predict: How will changes help?
  3. Rebuild (25 minutes):

    • Make improvements to prototype
    • Test frequently as you modify
    • Document changes in notebook
  4. Final Testing (10 minutes):

    • Official test of improved design
    • Record results
    • Compare: Original vs. improved version
    • Calculate: Percentage improvement (if measurable)

Improvement Documentation:

Original Design Results:
[specific measurements or observations]

Changes Made:
1.
2.
3.

Improved Design Results:
[specific measurements or observations]

Percent Improvement:
[if measurable]

Explanation:
Why did these changes help?
  1. Reflection (5 minutes):
    • Write reflection:
      • What was the most important improvement?
      • If you had more time, what else would you try?
      • How did understanding magnets help your design?

Practice Activity 3: Engineering Showcase and Evaluation (45 minutes)

Showcase Format:

  1. Setup (5 minutes):

    • Teams set up display:
      • Final prototype
      • Engineering notebook
      • Sign explaining design
  2. Museum Walk (25 minutes):

    • Half of class stays with display, half walks
    • Switch at halfway point
    • Presenters demonstrate design and answer questions
    • Visitors complete feedback forms

Visitor Feedback Form:

Design Name: _________________

What I liked:

What impressed me about how they used magnets:

One suggestion:

Did it meet the criteria? Yes/No
Explain:
  1. Awards and Recognition (10 minutes):

    • Class votes on categories:
      • Most Creative Use of Magnets
      • Best Testing and Iteration
      • Clearest Explanation
      • Most Improved Design
      • Best Teamwork
    • Certificates or recognition for each category
    • Emphasize: All engineers succeeded in different ways
  2. Reflection (5 minutes):

    • Final class discussion:
      • What was hardest about being an engineer?
      • How did your understanding of magnets help?
      • What would you want to design next?

ASSESSMENT

Formative Assessment (Ongoing):

Observations:

  • Are students applying magnetic force concepts?
  • Do they identify criteria and constraints?
  • Are they testing and improving?

Notebook Checks:

  • Clear problem definition
  • Multiple solution ideas
  • Detailed testing documentation
  • Evidence of iteration

Summative Assessment:

Engineering Portfolio Rubric:

Criteria Developing (1) Proficient (2) Advanced (3)
Problem Definition Criteria or constraints unclear Clearly identifies criteria and constraints Explains why criteria and constraints matter
Scientific Knowledge Little connection to magnetic concepts Applies magnetic force concepts correctly Explains how magnetic properties enable solution
Multiple Solutions One idea only 2-3 different solutions sketched 4+ creative solutions, compares strengths
Testing Minimal or no testing Tests against criteria, records results Multiple tests, quantitative data, analysis
Iteration No changes made Makes improvements based on testing Systematic improvements with clear reasoning
Communication Incomplete or unclear documentation Clear sketches and explanations Detailed documentation, presents well

Point Total: _____ / 18


EXTENSIONS AND MODIFICATIONS

For Advanced Students:

  1. Additional Constraints:

    • Limit to specific number of materials
    • Add cost constraints (assign prices to materials)
    • Time constraints: Design must work in under 30 seconds
  2. Complex Challenges:

    • Design using both attraction AND repulsion
    • Create design that works underwater (in plastic bag)
    • Design adjustable-strength magnetic tool
  3. Engineering Connections:

    • Research real-world applications: maglev trains, recycling separators, medical devices
    • Redesign for different scale (very large or very small)

For Students Needing Support:

  1. Simplified Challenges:

    • Reduce number of criteria (focus on 1-2)
    • Provide step-by-step building instructions for base design
    • Allow longer building time
  2. Scaffolded Planning:

    • Provide partially complete design templates
    • Offer example solutions to analyze first
    • Partner with more confident student
  3. Modified Materials:

    • Pre-select materials kit for each team
    • Stronger magnets for easier success
    • Provide pre-cut cardboard pieces

Cross-Curricular Connections:

Math:

  • Measure materials and forces
  • Graph test results
  • Calculate percentages (improvement, success rate)

Writing:

  • Technical writing (procedures)
  • Persuasive writing (convince someone your design is best)
  • Reflection writing

Art:

  • Aesthetic design elements
  • Clear visual communication in diagrams
  • Presentation and display

RESOURCES AND REFERENCES

PBS LearningMedia Resources:

Additional Resources:

Material Sources:

  • Magnets: Amazon, educational supply stores, science kits
  • Building materials: Craft stores, recycled materials, dollar stores
  • Testing equipment: School supply closet, borrow from upper grades

PARENT COMMUNICATION

Send Home Letter:

Dear Families,

We're starting an exciting unit on forces and motion! Your child will:
- Investigate how forces make objects move
- Explore magnets and static electricity
- Design and build solutions to engineering challenges

HOW YOU CAN HELP:
1. Save materials: Cardboard tubes, boxes, bottle caps
2. Explore at home: Refrigerator magnets, static electricity with balloons
3. Ask questions: "What forces do you see?" "How does that work?"

VOCABULARY TO PRACTICE:
- Force, push, pull, motion
- Balanced, unbalanced
- Attract, repel, magnetic

Watch for updates about our Engineering Showcase!

Thank you for supporting your child's learning!

End of Physical Science Guide

Total Guide: 15-20 hours of instruction
Includes: Setup, instruction, practice, and assessment
Aligned to NGSS 3-PS2-1, 3-PS2-2, 3-PS2-3, 3-PS2-4

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment